Sunday, November 3, 2013

Impressive Acting Drives Up An Otherwise Average A Perfect Man!


The Good: Amazing acting, Decent emotional conflict for the characters, Good character development
The Bad: Formulaic plot, Overbearing soundtrack.
The Basics: A Perfect Man explores the destruction of a relationship, the loneliness the unfaithful man feels afterward and the cautious hope embodied by the woman determined to put her life back together again!


It’s turning into a Liev Schreiber day for me. Schreiber was the star in the science fiction film I watched this morning, The Last Days On Mars and tonight, he was second-billed behind Jeanne Tripplehorn in the limited-release A Perfect Man. It is hard not to give credit immediately to director Kees Van Oostrum; Van Oostrum manages to present Schreiber as initially cold and menacing, but quickly brings him from aloof into dead sexy. The transition happens so fast that it almost seems like Schreiber’s character, James, is suffering from a split personality disorder. Van Oostrum keeps the performance tight, though, so Schreiber never strays over the line into making the viewer doubt the character’s mental health (though we quickly come to doubt his moral intergrity).

Starting with the complicated performance Liev Schreiber is important; it makes the character of Nina, played by Jeanne Tripplehorn, make much more sense right off the bat. Tripplehorn is good, but it is easy to brush her character’s enlightened views about relationships off until one sees Schreiber’s nuanced performance. Schreiber silently portrays the idea that even a man who has fidelity issues can still have a genuine – or convincing – love for his wife and when Nina sees that in him, her character becomes much more layered and real.

After picking Nina up in a bar, James seduces her. They are married shortly thereafter. Over nine years later, Nina and her friend/client Lynne follow Nina’s running buddy, Martha into the nearby city. Nina is suspicious because Martha hates the city and there she witnesses Martha having an affair with James. Revealing to Lynne that this is not the first affair that James has had, Nina does not call James out on his infidelity. James, for his part, seems interested in continuing the marriage . . . right up until the moment, at their anniversary party, when Nina calls him out on his affairs and announces that the pair is splitting up.

Despite James desperately trying to cling to Nina – though ruining her luggage does not make him feel better – Nina leaves and moves in with Lynn. While Lynn brings Nina out for a night on the town, James is approached by Laura, the college aged daughter of a woman he once had an affair with. As James walks home through Amsterdam at night, he finds himself contemplating his life and decisions. Despite the many temptations thrown his way, James resists having a separation affair on Nina. Nina, in recovering her laptop from the apartment, sees another side of James (the one she fell in love with) and she concocts a plan to get James interested in her again. She calls him up, pretending to call the dog, and gets James talking to her. James opens up to Janika, not knowing that it is Nina and they develop an over-the-phone relationship.

A Perfect Man starts out much like The Story Of Us (reviewed here!), without all of the yelling. The film transitions well, motivated by the characters, into a story of people actually developing a relationship with one another again. James is realistically shattered by Nina leaving; as if he had never actually considered the magnitude of his indiscretion and the probability that Nina would actually leave.

The somewhat contrived plot device of Nina re-seducing James over the phone is presented in an engaging fashion. It is interspersed well with scenes that have James’s mother visiting and giving insight into James’s character faults. A Perfect Man manages to be moody without losing its entertainment value and while the plot follows somewhat formulaically, it actually seems organically moved by the characters. James is presented as truly lost enough to talk on the phone to a stranger that calls and A Perfect Man is realistic in its portrayal of a man lost.

Unlike most romantic dramas or romantic comedies (and, despite the overuse of the soundtrack, A Perfect Man definitely falls on the dramatic side), Nina’s utterly contrived attempt to determine how James actually feels never comes across as ridiculous. In fact, even the moment when Nina (as Janika) picks up the phone the first time James calls back, Nina does not seem either goofy or desperate, which would have been a death knell for the film.

The strength of Nina comes down to the performance by Jeanne Tripplehorn. Tripplehorn is subtle and loving, strong without being a parody of feminism, and hopeful but cautious alternatively as Nina and she sells every emotion she is asked to portray. In fact, her performance is so good, it is shocking she does not get more first-billed roles! The magic of Jeanne Tripplehorn in A Perfect Man is that she can convincingly play a wide range of emotions with minimal facial movements and vocal inflections, while still making Nina seem like a viable, realistic character.

Together, Tripplehorn and Schreiber do on-screen what very few on-screen couples are ever able to pull off. They make their characters seem like they once had viable chemistry, lost it, and they make the process of finding love for one another again interesting to watch.

While A Perfect Man might not be the most original story told on film this year, it is bound to be one of the most underrated; the film has powerhouse acting and characters who are far more complex than most films allow.

For other films that explore complications in relationships, please check out my reviews of:
Mr. Morgan's Last Love
Unfinished Song
A Late Quartet
The Best Offer

6/10

For other film reviews, please check out my Movie Review Index Page for an organized listing!

© 2013 W.L. Swarts. May not be reprinted without permission.
| | |

Madonna Lives Up To Her Hype With Ray Of Light


The Good: A solid dance-pop album, Generally decent vocals, music, and lyrics
The Bad: Works better as a collection of singles than as a cohesive album
The Basics: Madonna manages to impress me with her lyrics on a series of songs that only seem to fail when she mortgages the emotional resonance to get the listener to dance.


What makes a hit or a hit artist? The latter question may be answered simply by "staying power." Artists who endure are the ones who simply remain in the public's imagination and consciousness long enough and successfully enough that regardless of other trends in music at the time, the artist is able to market their own work. With Madonna's recent Confessions On A Dance Floor which has inexplicably sold 8 million copies worldwide - only the first single broke the Hot 100 in the U.S. - one might be doubting Madonna's relevance. I was recently taken to task after reviewing Bedtime Stories for neglecting to mention "Human Nature" a "hit" that only reached 46 on the Top 100. Regardless of that, Madonna had a commercial resurgence after the lukewarm sales of Erotica and Bedtime Stories (how we may consider 5 and 6 million units sold worldwide, respectively, lukewarm is only because of context), with Ray Of Light.

It's a good album, it's easy to see why it sold 14 million copies in the world, four million in the U.S. alone. Ray Of Light is a thirteen track album clocking in at an hour seven minutes. The album was released as the singles market essentially collapsed and success of singles was tracked by points as opposed to sale of physical singles (which were becoming produced less and less by 1998). Madonna seemed to know how to capitalize on that - I've long agreed she is a brilliant businesswoman - and Ray Of Light (the album) charted four singles in the U.S. and an additional one in Canada and Europe. It's fairly impressive these days when an artist can get three successful singles charting, but with Ray Of Light, Madonna did it. This album saw the mainstream hit singles "Frozen," “Ray Of Light,” "The Power of Good-bye" and the flop "Nothing Really Matters,” which peaked at 93 on the Hot 100, though it went to #1 on the Dance charts.

My point in this is that when Madonna reinvents herself, sometimes she does a great job. Ray Of Light is a weird reinvention that brings Madonna back to her dance roots with tracks like “Ray Of Light” and "Nothing Really Matters" and combines them with more mature pop ballads like "Frozen." As a result, Madonna sounds like . . . well, an adult, on tracks like "Swim."

Ray Of Light features Madonna's creative vision as she co-wrote and co-produced all thirteen song. While she does not play any instruments on Ray Of Light, she provides the vocals and they are decent. Indeed, on the album's opener, the slow, sad ballad "Drowned World/Substitute For Love," Madonna's voice is stark, underproduced and in the face of the listener. Honestly, it was hearing this song that I first truly realized that Madonna has the ability to sing.

Moreover, what Madonna is singing on this album is generally more personal and as a result, her ability to emote comes through better. On another of her slower songs, "Frozen," she powerfully and simply sings out "You only see what your eyes want to see / How can life be what you want it to be / You're frozen / When your heart's not open / You're so consumed with how much you get / You waste your time with hate and regret / You're broken / When your heart's not open." Madonna's ability to sing is coupled with poetics that actually say something! Indeed, songs like "Frozen" remind the listener how decent pop-rock music can be when it is well constructed. On tracks like "Frozen," Madonna's purpose is not simply to move the listener into dancing and she effectively says something.

Similarly, Madonna seems to have a better balance on most of the tracks on Ray Of Light than she has on other albums of hers that I've listened to. So, for example, one of the tracks that could have been a hit but was never released as a single, "Swim," has a decent pop beat with minimal production elements. The understated drums and the addition of a flute allow Madonna's voice to come to the forefront. And her song actually says something. "Swim" wonderfully expresses a sense of misery that the narrator is trying to cleanse themself of. Madonna sings "Comets fly across the sky / While the churches burn their preachers / We can't carry these sins on our back / Don't wanna carry anymore . . ." ("Swim") and because Madonna is trying to sing something that means something, she's successful at accenting what is important in her songs.

That's not to say Ray Of Light is devoid of flaws, far from it. The title track, “Ray Of Light,” is more or less your typical pop-dance song that is overproduced and whose purpose is mostly to convince the listener to move their body. But at least that song makes sense. Having listened to the album several times now, "Shanti/Ashtangi" continues to bewilder me. The song is not in English (it utilizes Sanskrit phrases) and it feels out of place and somewhat pointless on this album.

Amid Madonna singing about cleansing, day to day life, expectations of youth imposed by society ("Candy Perfume Girl"), and the importance of expressing the spirit we supposedly all have, Madonna throws in a random prayer song. On other albums, this might be seen as a desperate attempt to make something relevant and meaningful, but Ray Of Light overcomes the limitations of simple pop-rock to actually do that with the lyrics to most of its songs. Indeed, were it not for Madonna's obsession with putting lines like "Looking at my life / It's very clear to me / I've lived so selfishly / I was the only one / I realize / That nobody wins / Something is ending / Something begins" ("Nothing Really Matters") to a dance beat, this album could be a knockout of Madonna's lyrical and musical self expression.

In short, Ray Of Light reveals a Madonna whose only real failure is her obsession with production. "Skin" works fine as a dance track, but it's Madonna's obsession with creating dance tracks here that undermines the strengths of Ray Of Light. For a change, most of her lyrics are solid, expressive and interesting. On several of the tracks, Madonna actually creates a combination of music and lyrics that comes together lushly in a way that suggests she is an artist more than an entrepreneur.

It's ironic for someone with such business savvy as Madonna that when I sit and listen objectively to Ray Of Light, I see an artist who seems afraid. Madonna's Ray Of Light leaves the listener with the impression that she is afraid of producing an album that is all ballads, that is soulful in lyrics and music. She opts for the safe route with much of the album as far as creating dance tracks out of songs that are lyrically ballads.

That's not to say that even all of those attempts are bad. "The Power of Good-bye" is a ballad, which is accented by a strong dance beat behind the string arrangement. There she effectively fuses voice, music and even her desire to create something that can be danced to. "The Power of Good-bye," despite not breaking into the top ten on the Hot 100, remains one of the most potent Madonna hits and it illustrates how commanding Madonna may be over the genre.

So, why is she so obsessed with dancing?

Sigh. Regardless, Ray Of Light is a solid pop-rock album with a number of pop-dance songs and while the tracks may work independently, some of the way the tracks fall along the album cuts into the emotional resonance of the track prior or after. Still, it's the best I've heard from Madonna yet.

The best song is "Frozen," the low point is "Shanti/Ashtangi."

For other works by Madonna, please check out my reviews of:
Erotica
Bedtime Stories
“Nothing Really Matters” (single)
Music
Confessions On A Dance Floor

7/10

For other music reviews, please check out my Music Review Index Page for an organized listing!

© 2013, 2007 W.L. Swarts. May not be reprinted without permission.
| | |

Indistinct, But At Least Jif Creamy Cashew Butter Is Ridiculously Expensive!


The Good: Does not taste bad, Very easy to use, No storage issues
The Bad: Exceptionally expensive, Not distinctly cashew flavored, Not crunchy, Nutrition.
The Basics: Jif Creamy Cashew Butter is entirely unmemorable and likely to be overshadowed by any food it is paired with, making it easy not to recommend.


My father is – or used to be, in my childhood – a huge fan of cashew nuts. So, given that it had been so long since I reviewed Jif Mocha Cappuccino Flavored Hazelnut Spread (that’s here!), I thought it might be fun to try Jif’s new Creamy Cashew Butter for review and the potential as a gift to my father. Sadly for the patriarch, he will not be getting Creamy Cashew Butter for his stocking this year and I feel like a chump for shelling out $6.00 just to try a 12 oz. container.

Creamy Cashew Butter is essentially peanut butter, made with cashews instead of peanuts, and sadly this does not make for an inherently exceptional product on any front!

Basics

Jif Creamy Cashew Butter is a flavored nut spread produced by Jif. It is a new nut spread that is part of their expanding line of other nut butters. It would not surprise me if this ended up on a clearance shelf near you in the days to come; it is vastly overpriced for the volume and not memorable on the tongue.

Jif’s Creamy Cashew Butter comes in the company’s small 12 oz. plastic jar. The Creamy Cashew Butter is light pale yellow-tan and creamy and the container comes with an easy to unscrew lid that keeps it fresh use after use!

Ease Of Preparation

Jif is a peanut butter-like spread, so there is not much needed in terms of preparation. Simply unscrew the plastic cap, tear off the foil safety seal below that and consume! It is that simple.

Taste

Opening the container of Jif Creamy Cashew Butter, the consumer is greeted by a warm, nutty smell. The aroma is not distinct to cashews (truth be told,I’ve never found cashews to be terribly aromatic or distinctive). The scent is not uninviting, but it is not powerful. For some reason, I’m associating the scent with a Chinese food recipe my father used to make that had had both fish and tomatoes (not my favorite).

In the mouth, Jif Creamy Cashew Butter is dry and buttery, with an indistinct nut flavor. The usual meatiness of cashew nut flavor only asserts itself as the cashew butter’s aftertaste. There is an unburnt nut flavor that mixes with the oily, buttery initial flavor to keep this from tasting like peanut butter, but largely, until the aftertaste kicks in, this is a shockingly indistinct flavor. In fact, given how the Cashew Butter cannot even be reasonably called sweet, it is a surprise that Jif produced this.

The flavor of the Creamy Cashew Butter is so weak that when it is added to a sandwich, the flavor of any jelly or jam I have yet tried easily overwhelms the cashew butter flavor. In fact, some breads even overcome the flavor of the cashew butter!

While the flavor of cashews briefly crosses the tongue for a few seconds, after the mass has been swallowed, there is no distinct or lasting aftertaste from Jif Creamy Cashew Butter.

Nutrition

Obviously, as a nut spread, Jif cannot do much about the lack of nutrition with their spread. Given that the spread is made largely of roasted cashews, sunflower oil, and sugar, this was never going to be a nutritious product. There is nothing terrible or unrecognizable in this spread, though.

It is also not the best product in the world for you on a nutrition front. A 2 Tbsp serving of Jif Creamy Cashew Butter has 200 calories, 160 of which are from fat. Those 18 grams of fat represent 27% of one’s RDA of fat. Unsurprisingly, one serving is 3% of your RDA of carbohydrates, though there is a decent 4 grams protein in this spread. There are, however, 105 mg of sodium in the nut spread. This is not a food to try to live off of, even with its smattering of Iron and Calcium.

This Cashew Butter is not marked as kosher and includes an allergy warning for those allergic to cashews, almonds, hazelnuts, and brazil, macadamia, and pine nuts.

Storage/Cleanup

Keep the spread sealed and it will last for quite some time. The container we bought a couple months ago would have expired on May 22 2014, had I not eaten it all up! This spread remains supple and spreadable indefinitely.

As a product made mostly of nuts, the Jif Creamy Cashew Butter is very easy to clean up. Simply washing it off with hot water helps clean off anything this gets on. Hot water is recommended because it is a bit oily.

Overall

I usually try to reserve any food in the 2 – 3 range for foods that might taste bad, but have nutritional value; for Jif Creamy Cashew Butter, I made an exception. Jif Creamy Cashew Butter does not taste bad at all, but it is indistinct and so very expensive for what one gets that it gets knocked down appropriately. Consumers will not have a bad flavor experience with this, they will have an unmemorable one and that is way too much to pay for something unmemorable!

For other food reviews, please check out my reviews of:
Jell-O Chocolate Mousse
Kernel Season's Kettle Corn Popcorn Seasoning
Nutella Hazelnut Spread

2.5/10

For other food reviews, please visit my Food Review Index Page for an organized listing!

© 2013 W.L. Swarts. May not be reprinted without permission.
| | |

More Than Just A Space Horror With An External Threat, The Last Days On Mars Is Clever!


The Good: Wonderful acting, Interesting characters, Interesting conflict, Mood
The Bad: Mars setting looks like a desert, Somewhat predictable horror plot progression
The Basics: While it might be easy to write off The Last Days On Mars as a zombie movie in space, it is actually smarter than one might expect and it deserves to be seen!


With the abysmal failure of John Carter (reviewed here!) at the box office, it is little surprise that moviegoers and production companies would be hesitant to return to Mars. Given the dramatic success of Gravity (reviewed here!)at the box office this year, though, it is surprising that The Last Days On Mars is not being pushed for a wider release. Like Gravity, The Last Days On Mars has a generally practical approach to near-Earth space travel and it is hard not to get the feeling that the international space community is softening up the population for a disaster in space, with the underlying argument that it is worth it for humanity to try at least.

After an initial, practical, set-up, with Vincent and some of the rest of the crew on edge about the six month trip that it will take to get from Mars to Earth, the film turns into something much more like Alien (reviewed here!). The Last Days On Mars starts with tightly realistic characters – the professionals have different specialties and there is a realistic psychological concern about how the explorers are doing in their last hours on Mars. The Last Days On Mars has a stark sense of isolation that makes the viewer feel like the Aurora crew is very much on its own, depending on one another under harsh circumstances.

The second Aurora mission to Mars is in its last twenty hours when a sandstorm hits the equipment that the Earth team is leaving on Mars. Petrovic and Harrington go out using the excuse that they need to fix equipment damaged in the storm before the team leaves Mars, though en route Petrovic reveals that there is a microscopic anomaly was detected. Moments after Kim Aldrich realizes that Marko Petrovic would not have gone outside just to make repairs, Petrovic extracts what appears to be a life form from the ground right before it collapses. With Petrovic killed, Captain Brunel works to maintain order among the crew.

While Aldrich tries to impress upon the others the magnitude of the discovery of a microscopic life form, Brunel reluctantly goes out to recover Petrovic’s body. Vincent descends into the hole in the ground, where he sees webbing that makes him believe there is something alive in the pit. Unable to find the bodies of Marko or Dalby (who is also missing by that point), the team outside is shocked when they find tracks leading away from the pit. Soon, the base is under siege by its dead and transformed crewmembers. The survivors struggle to get off Mars while eluding their transformed comrades.

Right off the bat, The Last Days On Mars disappointed me from its look. The film looks like it was filmed in the desert . . . which it was. The Last Days On Mars does not feel like it is set on an alien world, so the sand looks brown, not red or orange. With the addition of a water spire, the setting feels even more like Earth. This undermines the film some because the viewer has to be told of the threats and reminded of them, like the inherent danger of getting a tear in the suit each explorer wears when outside the base on Mars.

The look of The Last Days On Mars does not hold the film back for very long. Instead of belaboring the production values of the outside the station sequences, the film gets pretty fast back inside where both the characters and the impending horror are explored. Vincent suffers from claustrophobia and as the viewer is taken back to the space ship upon which the crew arrived, they instantly understand Vincent’s ambivalence to the return trip. As well, Vincent has one of the great, realistic moments in the film when Aldrich wants to know about the capabilities of the undead crewmembers and his response is an honestly realistic, “How the fuck should I know?!” The characters do not have the time or resources to truly understand what they are up against, so they are forced to rely upon common sense and that works well for the movie. Mirroring the fantastic plot of the infected astronauts is Vincent’s struggle against his very realistic claustrophobia. It’s reminiscent of Garak’s arc in “By Inferno’s Light” (reviewed here!) and it plays a bit more realistically in The Last Days On Mars. The struggle against his own fears are not simply shrugged off for plot convenience, which is nice.

What initially impressed me about The Last Days On Mars was how well-defined each character was. The team on the Aurora mission has pretty clear jobs: Brunel is the Captain, there is a psychologist, a doctor and a mechanic aboard, the rest of the crew seems like they could realistically be astronauts. Aldrich makes some excellent points about how the crew is suddenly trusting people who have already proven to be untrustworthy and that type of realism is something I’ve not seen in film before.

While Liev Schreiber gets top billing, Olivia Williams’s Aldrich is more immediately engaging. Aldrich is characterized by Vincent as a bitch, but she is smart and capable. Before the mission goes to pot, she is on top of things. Williams plays Aldrich with a clear intelligence and ability that makes the viewer root for her. In fact, more than Ripley in Alien, Aldrich becomes an efficient, intelligent character viewers want to survive. Williams is articulate and carries the fight sequences she is in remarkably well. While other characters in similar films fall apart, Aldrich comes up with a medical cocktail that might thwart her undead compatriots and she immediately sets to testing it. Williams presents Aldrich with a fearless and scientifically-reasonable quality that makes her both a likable pragmatist and a believable professional.

For his part, Liev Schreiber plays the fear for Vincent exceptionally well. More than that, Schreiber was perfectly cast for the character’s sarcasm and realistic sense of futility. When Vincent is attacked by one of the creatures and it just keeps coming, his exasperation is perfectly presented by Schreiber. As the film starts to drag in the last half, Schreiber adequately carries it with his quiet moodiness, making Vincent interesting to watch. The rest of the cast plays their parts well and all of them seem like they could realistically be in the positions they are in.

The Last Days On Mars accomplishes what few science fiction horror movies are able to, even if it does not look like it is set on Mars: it realistically captures the horrors of being alone, without resources, without information, without hope. And it does that very well, making it well worth watching, even when it is derivative.

For other science fiction horror films, please check out my reviews of:
Pitch Black
Predators
Underworld

8/10

For other movie reviews, please visit my Movie Review Index Page for an organized listing!

© 2013 W.L. Swarts. May not be reprinted without permission.
| | |

Saturday, November 2, 2013

It Is Time To Abolish The “Minimum Hourly Wages For Tipped Employees” (And Two Other Mandates To Help The Working Poor!)

| | |
The Basics: Server minimum wage and workplace rules for tipping out other employees and buying uniforms undermine the intent of minimum wage law, keep hard-working servers poor, and should be abolished immediately.


Once upon a time, government was not treated as Public Enemy Number One. In truth, it was not a terribly long time ago that the United States Government actually worked hard to protect the citizens it governed. Back during the Great Depression, the United States Government stood up against the economic forces that were steamrolling citizens and leaving millions of people poor, homeless and dying young. While FDR’s New Deal programs took some hits from the Supreme Court, back in those days, the government acted as a force of good for the people and stood up to business interests. A few decades later, the Federal Government stood up again and again to pass Civil Rights legislation that worked to protect the rights of legally-disenfranchised citizens. The point here is that with the creation of the minimum wage, social welfare programs, and civil rights legislations, the United States government actually has a history of trying to protect its citizens from fear, poverty and abuse from corporate interests.

As I put the final touches on my revolutionary new economic theory (forthcoming next week!), I have become increasingly troubled by the legal safeguards to businesses that exist to the detriment of citizens. I recently explored how protecting the business interests of health insurance companies is actually a First Amendment violation (check out that article here!) and tonight I take on Server Minimum Wage.

What Is Server Minimum Wage?

I am an educated writer. I might only have a Bachelor’s Degree (in English), but I am well-read and I generally keep informed. Back during the Bush Administration, I ran for the United States House Of Representatives before it was popular or politically safe to speak out against the Bush Administration and its tactics. So, I was pretty shocked when, after thirty-two years of life, I was informed that there is a separate minimum wage for tipped employees.

If you’re like me, you might have gone out to restaurants for most of your life, tipping the appropriate 15 – 25% (or more for exceptionally good service) completely ignorant of the dependence those waitresses and waiters had on those tips. The word “dependence” is an accurate one. In all but seven states, tipped employees are subject to a reduced minimum wage (five states do not have any minimum wage laws and are guided by the Federal minimum wage). According to the U.S. Department Of Labor, the nationally-mandated minimum wage right now is a pathetically low $7.25 (a rate that the Housing Department has found will not allow a minimum wage employee to afford a fair-market apartment in any state of the union on one’s own!). Outside seven states and Guam, the Federal Government has declared the minimum hourly wage for tipped employees to be $2.13. The theory of the lower minimum wage is that the server or other tipped employee will make up the difference ($5.12/hr.) in tips and the wage and tips will average out in a pay period to at least $7.25/hr.

Of the forty-three states that allow a minimum wage for tipped employees (which I will henceforth be calling “server minimum wage”), nineteen of them use the federally-mandated $2.13/hour (Georgia tipped employees are “exempt” from the minimum wage law!). The highest server minimum wage is in Hawaii ($7/hr.), followed by West Virginia ($5.80/hr.). In most of the states that allow a reduced server minimum wage, servers count on tips in order to make up the difference between the server minimum wage and actual minimum wage.

Personal Digression

Having been married for years to a pretty fabulous woman who is an amazing waitress, I’ve come to develop some strong feelings on the server minimum wage. It is worth noting up front that my wife and I differ on the forthcoming theory. While she believes my latter two points are valid, she was of a mindset that it would be disastrous to abolish the server minimum wage. Her argument is that if people did not feel compelled to tip to make up the wages of the employees, they would simply stop tipping. Her argument is also that many servers would get out of the profession if there were no tips or they could not rely upon tips.

So, up front, let me say: 1. I am not advocating against tipping servers (tip your servers generously or don’t bother going out to eat at a restaurant where tipping is appropriate!), 2. As my argument will show, despite my wife’s assertions, tips are hardly a reliable form of income, and 3. If there was a great migration of servers out of the serving industry based on changing server minimum wage laws, there is a good chance it would aid the economy (though I suspect there is not a vast population of workers waiting to change out of a serving career based only on their tips; those who receive great tips now would likely still get great tips on top of their wages if the law was changed).

An Argument To Abolish The Server Minimum Wage

Since the creation of Federal and State-based minimum wage guidelines, Federal law has fallen very firmly to the benefit of businesses, as opposed to workers. One need only look at the creation of the server minimum wage to see how the law looks to protect business interests as opposed to workers rights. Tips are, by their definition, intended as a gift for exceptional service. Why, then, is there a minimum hourly wage for tipped employees? The answer is simple: it allows business owners to keep expenses down and compels employees to spend the “gift” (tip) as a wage. The tips come in and go out; the business owner records them, but often only pays a wage to employees in the form of tax withholdings.

The concept of server minimum wage is an inherently unfair one. By creating a separate class of employees, paid at a lower rate, the government and society are placing an instant value judgment on the work being done. Stocking shelves, working as a cashier, cooking food in microwaves at a fast food restaurant are all valued (by minimum wage law) more than serving food, interacting with customers, upselling and moving around on one’s feet for hours on end. Servers have a far more complicated job than legislators give them credit for: when they are waiting on tables, they are seldom waiting on just one table and they have to put up with demanding customers, ornery cooks, and management that is trained to undervalue them. Servers are treated as servants, babysitters, messengers, couriers, and cleaners . . . usually for multiple tables at once.

There might have been a time when server minimum wage made sense (I’m at a loss to believe there was a time when it was sensible to pay the people who bring you food and drink less than the guy who folds shirts at the Gap), but a recession is not that time. Politicians loathe using the word recession and there are specific economic conditions that must be met in order to declare a period a recession. When the economy is struggling, it is not the time to have a server minimum wage. The argument from politicians and businesses are that the economy needs businesses to survive and keeping labor costs low is essential. Business will always seek to keep labor costs low; expecting “the market” to raise worker wages based on ability and profitability of workers is like expecting a compulsive gambler to quit while they’re ahead or sharks to stop a feeding frenzy because they’ve eaten to physical capacity or any number of other things that would happen in a “fair” world that do not happen in ours. Businesses are exceptionally good at looking out for their own interests and the fact that so many politicians prioritize keeping businesses running over keeping citizens fed, clothed, and housed, is troubling.

When there is an economic downturn, recession, slow growth, it is exactly the time to do away with the server minimum wage. Economists (as opposed to humanists – the people who care more about people than business interests) will say that people using disposable income to go out to dinner or travel helps with stimulating the economy. The problem with this mindset is that it assumes all people who are going out to dinner are tipping, as appropriate, in order to cover the gaps in the server minimum wage. Experience has shown they are not. Cheap people, poor people, teenagers, and people who are on a fixed income do not tip more or as much when they themselves are strapped for cash (and/or are ignorant of the importance of tipping for paying the servers their wages). When the income tax refund comes and people in those demographics splurge, they seldom account for the tip. This was actually well-illustrated in Waiting . . . (reviewed here!) when the redneck diner takes his wife out for their anniversary and racks up a decent bill, but tips a pathetic quarter.

Those who fail to tip or fail to tip adequately do so at a cost to the server. Because the wages for the server are calculated with the expectation that the server is getting tips on each order and each hour, the underlying assumption is that the server is kept busy and satisfactorily delivers tipworthy service and that the customers are in a position to tip appropriately. But any one of those conditions not being met diminishes the servers rate of pay. The only one that the server controls is the service they deliver (and it can be tough when you’re harassed by the kitchen and demeaned by customers constantly). Unfortunately, delivering amazing customer service is not a guarantee that the other two conditions will be met (as is amply proven by the site my wife has become obsessed with, If You Can’t Afford To Tip, You Can’t Afford To Go Out And Eat!).

Conditions that are outside the server’s control can easily rob them of fair wages. How so? Let’s take a slow day. Let’s say on an uncommonly slow day, the manager overstaffs the restaurant and Waitress X ends up with only two tables in her section over the course of two hours. At $2.13/hr, she needs to make $10.24 in tips just to reach minimum wage. Table One is a pair of teenagers. They are on a cheap date, order the lunch specials, and rack up a bill that is less than $20. They’re young, inexperienced, and cheap and do not know to tip, but even if they did, the exceptional service Waitress X delivered would still only be worth $4 according to Federal calculations . . . which does not even get up to the $5.12 she needed to make that hour. But then, three businessmen come in and run Waitress X’s ass off for the second hour. They rack up a $50 bill, upon which they tip $10. $10 is still not $10.24, but the employer might shell out the $.24 they are supposed to to cover the difference in wages. Odds are, they would not have to; over the course of a pay period, the waitress might make up the difference through other tips . . . but she is only making her payroll for waiting on the teenagers because of the second table that came in. While she might have been tipped a fair amount for that table, the funds she earned are used to cover the lack of a tip from the other table.

In no other business are wages averaged out based on factors outside the worker’s control. In no other industry are sales (or deficiencies of sales) used to compensate for the base wage the worker makes. In other words, if you go into a big box electronics store, the workers are paid regardless of whether you buy the DVD they just stocked on the shelf or the video game they put out last week; their wages are not paid based on an aggregate of what customers spend over the course of their work week! It would be ridiculously complicated to do that, workers would not stand for it, and it would fundamentally undermine minimum wage laws. And the marketplace survives: it is the cost of doing business. Why, then, are restaurants, bars, and other service-based jobs exempt from the idea that they are valued (especially when they are usually much more interactive than in any other industry!)?

As well, servers wages can be dramatically affected by promotions outside their control. For example, many restaurants offer free meals to veterans on Veteran’s Day. No one would dispute the great sacrifices our soldiers, officers, enlisted personnel and other military staff make for our country. However, the promotion – which usually comes with a management demand for all hands on deck from serving staff for the busy day – is inherently unfair to tipped employees. If your bill is 0% or the cost of one meal for two (or more!) people at a table, the tip (if any) is disproportionately low for the server. 20% of 0% is $0. That means servers will work on Veteran’s Day, many without making tips or making far fewer tips than the amount of work they will do that day. Will the business make up the difference in wages? Most won’t; they will basically eat the surplus tips from other days in the pay period against the Veteran’s Day deficit. So, in addition to bearing the transport and time expenses of going into work, servers will likely bear an expense against prior or subsequent earnings to pay for their day’s work! Veterans have every reason to complain about the way they are treated after serving, but why should they treat servers as poorly?! Similarly, all coupons, happy hours, and specials reduce the server’s ability to make their wage while increasing their workload.

Server minimum wage invites abuse. Most servers are not legal scholars; they are working for minimum wages averaged over their workweek and they are largely un-Unionized, working without contracts, for employers who are institutionally valuing them less (cooks are protected by minimum wage law, while servers are paid 1/3 minimum wage!). So, if a server has a bad week and is undertipped and the employer does not pay them fairly to make up the difference to minimum wage, the server is seldom in a position to notice or have a reasonable mechanism to protest (and, given “right to work” laws, keep their job!). It is exceptionally easy for employers to avoid paying servers actual minimum wage (as they are legally obligated to do when the tip amounts do not average out to the actual minimum wage) when the tips fall short.

Moreover, workers paid bi-weekly can easily have deficits in their wages taken out of subsequent weeks! If a restaurant pays bi-weekly and a worker has one terrible week and one great week, it is very easy for the employer to make up the deficit from the bad week with the good week’s tips, though legally, that is not permitted.

Finally, the tips on paper are seldom indicative of the accurate wages the employee is making (see below!). Regardless, bookkeeping and paying wages are not what the server signed up for when they took a job in the service industry. On top of all their serving responsibilities, they should not be responsible for acting as a watchdog on the management of the facility at which they serve. Workers paid a steady wage or a fair, steady wage plus tips are not burdened with the worry that comes with depending upon the generosity of strangers or the additional watchdog responsibility that servers today have.

Why Eliminating The Server Minimum Wage Is Imperative

There are three key reasons to eliminate the server minimum wage: Integrity of minimum wage law, cultural benefits, and the business benefit.

Congress is exceptionally good at looking out for businesses; there are loopholes in the Affordable Care Act that encourage employers to keep workers at part-time and pass the financial and administrative burdens of health care onto the workers. Financial institutions are not comfortable with variables; server minimum wage undermines the worker’s ability to get car loans, mortgages, and pay other fixed bills. By having a separate class for servers, the government is codifying a division in the workplace that makes it inherently more difficult for individuals in the service industry to enjoy the benefits of employment. Minimum wage is barely a livable wage (it probably is not a livable wage for a single person anywhere in the nation); having a reduced minimum wage that can easily be lower than minimum wage undermines the philosophy of minimum wage and makes it more difficult for an entire industry of workers to be financially independent.

There is a huge cultural benefit to abolishing the server minimum wage as well. Servers are absolutely dependent upon tips right now in order to make their basic wages. If a customer is an asshole to them, they grin and bear it (more often than not) on the faint hope that the person who is treating them poorly will come through at the end and tip appropriately. This is an utterly unrealistic expectation. But, more than that, it encourages the asshole to continue to be an asshole and it entirely demeans every server forced to wait upon them. With a set basic wage, good servers need not put up with shit from assholes (that’s a sophisticated argument, I know, but bear it out); if you’re an asshole and come into a restaurant and treat your servers with disrespect, then you get your food and nothing else. Don’t tip, fine: your server is prioritizing the nice people who will treat them well and hopefully tip them. If you’re an asshole who is smart, you get the hint to stop treating servers poorly; if you’re an asshole and an idiot, you get poor service everywhere you go every time because of how you treat waitstaff. Eliminating the server minimum wage reduces the stress on servers and encourages jerks who want to go out to eat to treat their servers better (even if that is not reflected in tips).

Finally, there is a business benefit to abolishing the server minimum wage. While managers and business will complain that raising servers to at least minimum wage will cost them money (every business seeks to reduce labor costs – management loathes paying workers, but it is an expense and the cost of doing business and relying upon others to execute the vision they have for their business), they neglect the benefit. The government has a great incentive; higher pay rate for servers means more tax dollars (they can tax the hourly wage and the tips the worker receives!) for the governments to collect. But on the business end, having a higher labor rate inspires the managers to run the business more efficiently. Managers who place more value on their employees (reflected by rate) encourage them to staff appropriately, train adequately, and retain to their best benefit. If you are paying your workers more, you are less likely to overstaff during the slow times. You will want your workers to be trained to upsell and do their jobs better to encourage return visits. You will retain the most competent workers, as opposed to the cutest. There are business benefits to compelling business to raise their wages, especially for servers.

Server Minimum Wage Is Seldom An Accurate Reflection On Worker’s Wages

Finally, there are two aspects that legislators did not (adequately) consider when they conceived of and ratified server minimum wage: tip-outs and uniform expenses.

Tip-outs, for those not in the know, are financial obligations servers have to other personnel in the restaurant. A server in many establishments is expected to share their tips (even in places that do not pool tips!) with other workers at their establishment. So, a waitress may be expected to give a cut of their tips to bartenders (whether or not their customers ordered beverages the bartender prepared!) and server assistants. Server assistants are the employees who might clean up spills, clear tables, and seat customers for the servers. They are usually paid a higher rate than servers and their job is a catch-all . . . but that is what they are paid to do. Servers might be expected to tip-out to server assistants (2.5 – 5%) and bartenders (up to 10%) who are serving during their shift regardless of whether or not their services were used or how those personnel actually facilitated the orders. In Waiting . . ., as an example, the server assistants are characterized as two guys who spend the whole time getting high and seldom actually doing their jobs. Regardless of their competence, such employees are entitled to a fair wage of their own . . . one that the employer should be paying, not the servers.

To make matters worse, many places require tip-outs based upon the bill, not the actual tips. So, in our example above, when the teenagers spent $20 (but did not tip) and the businesspeople spent $50 (and tipped $10), Waitress X had to tip-out $1.75 to the server assistant and $7 to the bartender. So, the $10 tip that was supposed to make up the $10.24 wage deficit is now a $1.25 tip against the $10.24 deficit. The server literally paid the server assistant and bartender for the teenagers to have lunch in the establishment! It is utterly ridiculous to mandate that servers tip-out to their co-workers and to do so based on money they may not have actually received (the tip-out would have been about five cents to the server assistant and a dollar to the bartender if the tip-out was based on actual tips received!). Servers are not in the business of employing the bartender or server assistants; they should not bear the responsibility for their payroll. Having servers tip-out is like Bill Gates expecting the software engineers at Microsoft to pay the marketing department workers whenever the engineer writes a successful line of computer code.

Tip-outs should be abolished by law; if servers want to share, that should be their free will, not a condition of their employment at a facility.

Finally, servers are frequently screwed by the expense of uniforms. Many corporate work environments require a set uniform. While they might provide a shirt, they often require other uniform elements that are not provided for, either in materials or budget. Black pants, for example, are not free and anyone coming off being unemployed cannot be expected to show up to work when there are instantaneous expenses. Many servers have to buy their own aprons, pants, non-slip shoes, as well as have their own “bank” (cash on hand to make change for customers . . . which is not provided by the business! They always have to have $20 plus change just to show up at work!). These uniform requirements might be reasonable, but there is nothing to stop them from being ridiculous; at least one chain restaurant requires servers to wear a belt, despite the fact that their belt area is always covered by a bloused shirt bottom and an apron! Why should the workers bear the uniform expenses, especially when they are paid a reduced minimum wage?! The simple answer is that they should not! Uniform requirements would be much more reasonable (or easy to swallow) if those who are paid the least in the company did not bear the expense of them. Uniform requirements where neither uniforms, nor an adequate stipend for uniform purchases, are provided is an unfair burden on the workers.

What You Can Do!

For a change, this article is not only academic, it is interactive! Below is a simple form letter. Copy and paste the letter into your e-mail and send a copy (filling in the appropriate blanks) to your State AND Federal legislators. That’s your State Senator, State Assemblyperson, two Senators in the U.S. Senate, and one Representative in the United States House Of Representatives. Five e-mails to the five people who represent you in the bodies of government that can get this done. Then, please share a link to this article with all of your likeminded friends (or those who you think could be convinced by it!). The URL in your browser at the top can be copied and pasted into an e-mail to friends, family, and coworkers! Spread the word and we can make change!

Form letter to your legislators (cut and paste the following to e-mail to your legislators):

To The Honorable [insert name here];

The separate minimum wage for tipped employees is an unfair classification that puts undue burden on the finances and wellbeing of our servers and other tipped employees. Businesses that employ tipped employees should bear the responsibility of paying fair wages to their employees, instead of receiving government protection to pay them less.

To that end, I would ask you to sponsor and/or support legislation to:
1. Abolish the minimum wage for tipped employees and ensure tipped employees earn minimum wage plus any tips they receive,
2. Make tip-outs or any other form of payment that requires tipped employees to tip other employees at an establishment illegal, and
3. Make all required uniforms dictated by a business the financial responsibility of the employer. If an employer dictates a set uniform, they must provide or pay their minimum wage employees a stipend to get the uniform components.
Thank you for acting as a champion for the working-class!

Sincerely,
[insert your name here]




© 2013 W.L. Swarts. May not be reprinted without permission.
| | |

Ruining Character For Familiarity, The L Word Season Five Flounders!


The Good: Moments of character (Alice, Tasha, Max), Moments of performance, Narrative creativity
The Bad: Focus on Jenny, Not all of the narrative experiments work, Guts the character of Shane, Soap operatic qualities, Dawn Denbo subplot
The Basics: While trying to be fresh, The L Word clunks along in its fifth season, undermining much of the prior seasons’ character growth.


When I love a television series, there is very little that can keep me from plowing right through it. In the case of The L Word, I’ve enjoyed the first four seasons (despite the fact that the only casualty in the entire series was my favorite character!), but it took me two tries to get through the fifth season and since completing it, I’ve been sitting on the review for about a month. The reason is, honestly, I was caught between a 3.5 and a 4 out of ten rating. If the series had still been on the air when I watched it (and I thought I had any influence by reviewing it), I probably would have bumped it up to a four, if for no other reason than to encourage the creativity and the season’s lone heartfelt moment (I’ll admit, the climactic moment between Alice and Tasha in one of the last episodes of the season brought a tear to my eyes!).

But, as I had been warned by a friend and fan of the series, The L Word Season Five shows a marked decline in the show. While I enjoyed the way the producers, writers, and directors played with the narrative – many of the episodes have teasers that are campy dreams, alternate scenes – actresses on the set of the film Les Girls acting out prior scenes from the series and homages to other works – the fifth season goes into dramatically shakier territory and to go there, the series severely undermines much of the character growth of characters, most notably, Shane. As well, the fifth season – which has expanded the cast yet again – has a number of tangent stories that essentially go nowhere and, in the process, end up creating a much more soap operatic show than The L Word has been. In other words, realism is sacrificed for melodrama and those living outside Los Angeles are likely to find the season even more offputting than the prior ones.

Jenny rewrites the screenplay to Les Girls as Bette and Jodi work on their (now) long distance relationship. Jodi returns to Bette almost immediately, while Jenny becomes more a part of the Hollywood machine to get Les Girls made into a feature film. Max’s working for Alice is going well, though Alice marginalizes Max and she misses Tasha. Shane and Paige make a move toward being together, but Shane (characteristically) flips out. With Helena in jail, she becomes terrified by and enamored with her cellmate. Jenny continues to go through assistants while Shane goes through an entire wedding party following her breakup with Paige. As Tasha faces discharge from the military, Alice starts to fight for her.

Tina uses her friendship with Jenny to get her studio Les Girls, though she quickly discovers that the hassle of working with the increasingly difficult Jenny might not be worth it. Max and Kit discover a fan of Jenny’s, Adele, at The Planet and hook her up as Jenny’s new assistant. Max, though, starts to notice that Adele might not be all that she seems. Kit, for her part, is soon overwhelmed by competition from a new lesbian bar in town, one that goes to war with the Planet. With Jenny romancing the star of Les Girls and Tasha fighting for her military career, tensions in the group begin to run high . . . which puts Tina and Bette on a collision course with one another again!

In order to set off the ridiculous plot that has a new nightclub opening in Los Angeles that starts to mimic and poach from The Planet, Shane has to almost completely revert to her original characterization. Following her fleeing Carmen at the climax of season three (reviewed here!), Shane was in the perfect place to develop in season four (reviewed here!). The writers of The L Word smartly developed Shane; as she became closer to her father, she made a conscious effort to reject his parenting patterns by essentially becoming a mother to her young half-brother in season four. With his departure, Shane and Paige were together to raise Paige’s son and almost immediately that entire arc and years of character growth were cut down. The point of undermining Shane’s calculated and worthwhile character growth? So Shane could get into a threesome with Dawn Denbo and her girlfriend at the new nightclub in order to set off the jealous war that Denbo would then rage on The Planet.

This is not a good reason to ruin a character.

Shane is not the only character problematically undermined in Season Five. In order to make the growing passion Tina has for Bette work, the viewer has to forget how Tina was shattered by Bette cheating on her. But that is the folly of The L Word; none of the characters are reliably monogamous, though many claim that they want that type of love and lifestyle.

At the other end of the spectrum is Jenny Schecter. Jenny has become progressively worse over the seasons and in the fifth season she is the embodiment of the spoiled brat (there’s another B word or even C word that more accurately describes her character in this season!). Jenny has completely lost any sense of humbleness as she becomes a Hollywood stereotype and a jerk to everyone around her. In fact, despite the fact that Bette calls her out on her poor behavior, there is no real reason why any of the characters consider her a friend any longer (though, to be fair, she does get Shane a job as a hair stylist on the set of Les Girls and Shane stands by her for that reason).

The L Word, like all worthwhile shows, succeeds (when it does) because of the characters it presents. In the fifth season, the cast of characters includes:

Bette Porter – With her professional life generally placid, she focuses on her relationship with Jodi. Unfortunately for her, she has a disastrous weekend with Jodi’s friends (who are much livelier than she is), which ends abruptly when Kit is robbed at gunpoint at The Planet. She shares parenting duties with Tina and is furious with Jenny for what Jenny wrote about her in Les Girls. Despite loving Jodi, she finds herself drawn back to Tina as they share common challenges,

Tina Kennard – Quietly pines for Bette while putting up with Jenny at work. She is minimized this season until there comes an opportunity for her and Bette to rekindle their relationship and when their affair comes out during a bike-a-thon the group is on, she sympathizes with Jodi,

Jodi Lerner – The artist returns to Los Angeles for Bette. She complicates Bette’s professional life when she allows one of her artists to do a performance art piece where he appears to hold a gun to his own head. Personally, she is embarrassed by Bette when Bette is aloof during a weekend she plans with her friends. When she realizes Bette is still in love with Tina, she takes it poorly, publicly embarrassing her lover,

Shane McCutcheon – Cheats on Paige while looking for an apartment for the couple. When (probably) Paige burns down her hair salon, she refuses to press charges. She seduces an entire wedding party and gets involved with Dawn Denbo and, more significantly, Denbo’s partner. She stands by Jenny when the production of Les Girls is threatened,

Alice Pieszecki – Her star is on the rise. Her podcasts and radio show begin getting her real attention. That gets her invited to a posh, secret, gay’s only party in Hollywood. When Tasha accompanies her, she is shocked by a prominent athlete appearing at the party. She is furious when that same athlete is later quoted making homophobic remarks and Alice uses video footage to “out” him. When that makes Alice a bit of a celebrity, she is offered a chance to co-host a prominent morning show. As Alice is used against Tasha when Tasha is forced to defend herself against charges of homosexual conduct in the military, she accidentally stumbles upon Tasha’s salvation,

Tasha Williams – She is delayed from her deployment and when one of her fellow MPs sees her out in public with Alice, her career is menaced. After the hassle of convincing her JAG officer to advocate for her, she prepares to fight for her career, even as Alice is used against her,

Kit Porter – Is robbed at gunpoint, so she gets a gun. When Dawn Denbo makes a play to ruin her and The Planet, she gets into a murderous rage. On the verge of losing everything when Denbo is able to buy out The Planet, the most unlikely ally comes to her aid,

Max Sweeney – No longer determined to get gender reassignment surgery, the transgendered member of the group calls Alice out on her exclusion of transgendered individuals on her podcast. Max develops a crush on Jodi’s interpreter. Max is also the only member of the group to not trust Adele and work to expose Jenny’s new assistant,

Adele – A mysterious, initially mousy, young woman who is a fan of Jenny Schecter’s works. She becomes Jenny’s assistant and begins pursuing her own agenda. Her personal narrative contains a number of contradictions that only Max initially catches,

Phyllis Kroll – Alice’s former lover and Bette’s boss pops up periodically, though she offends Joyce and then later needs her legal services,

Helena Peabody – Absent most of the season, she is imprisoned for her crimes in the prior season before skipping town prior to her trial. She returns when her mother is dying after having fallen in love with her cellmate,

And Jenny Schecter – Returning to Los Angeles with the financial backing of a sugar daddy who is enamored with her work, she weasels her way into being the director of Les Girls. After Adele and Tina convince Jenny to cast Nikki Stevens as the lead in the film, Jenny and Nikki begin a romantic relationship which threatens production of the film! She treats everyone around her like a tool and exhibits little humanity in dealing with others.

In the fifth season of The L Word, the acting is fine, which sells many of the teasers – like the campy Charlie’s Angels parody that opens one of the episodes – but few of the performers are given much to do that actually stretches their talents. Arguably the best performance of the season is one of the most simple and profound: late in the season, actress Rose Rollins is able to stretch Tasha in a new direction. Adrift and without order, Rollins makes a simple moment of being compelling and fascinating to watch. The rest of the cast does what is asked of them, but there are no extraordinary performances for the remainder of the season.

The L Word Season 5 is not abysmal, but it lacks a compelling element to make it worth recommending or watching. The story of lesbian culture in Los Angeles has become unfortunately inbred in this season and, lacking anything real, it treads toward the melodramatic and soap operatic.

For other works with Wally Shawn, please visit my reviews of:
Toy Story 3
Furry Vengeance
Southland Tales
The Incredibles
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
The Princess Bride

3.5/10

For other television reviews, please visit my Television Review Index Page for an organized listing!

© 2013 W.L. Swarts. May not be reprinted without permission.
| | |

Friday, November 1, 2013

Uninspiring Anthology: Suck It, Wonder Woman! Is An Unremarkable Collection!


The Good: Conversational writing style is fun, Some entertaining stories
The Bad: Not terribly original, insightful or clever, Repetitive
The Basics: Olivia Munn’s autobiographical essays and collection of philosophies, Suck It, Wonder Woman!, adds up to nothing of consequence.


I like Olivia Munn on The Newsroom (season two is now reviewed here!) and that was my impetus for picking up her book Suck It, Wonder Woman!. After my first night of reading Suck It, Wonder Woman!, my wife asked me what I thought of it and I frowned and noted that it wasn’t adding up to much. Her response was one of anything but surprise and she reminded me how much Olivia Minn rambled on the commentary track on the first season of The Newsroom (reviewed here!). I had forgotten how Munn dominated the audio track bonus feature on The Newsroom without, ultimately, saying much at all.

Outside The Newsroom, I had no experience with Olivia Munn until reading Suck It, Wonder Woman!,so I cannot offer a comparative analysis of how the book stacks up against her performances on Attack Of The Show. But, if Suck It, Wonder Woman! is any indication, Aaron Sorkin has seen a potential in Olivia Munn that is not at all evident in her writing. In other words, anyone hoping for a Sorkin-esque level of wit, depth and thematic sophistication will not find it from Olivia Munn, at least not in Suck It, Wonder Woman!. On The Newsroom, Munn is articulate and she delivers her lines entirely convincingly.

That voice is entirely absent from Suck It, Wonder Woman!

In Suck It, Wonder Woman!, Olivia Munn rambles from subject to subject; it begins as an autobiography and interspersed between stories of Munn’s life are her philosophies on various things. Her subjects of contemplations range from why one shouldn’t mix tequila and painkillers (it leads to homoerotic showers, apparently, which is not exactly the strongest argument against, despite the fact that it comes after nearly drowning) to why you should get a threesome out of the way if your boyfriend has not already had one. None of the passages are particularly insightful or authoritative, save the autobiographical bits. Munn describes her lonely childhood, early experiences in Hollywood (like meeting with a famous director who masturbated in front of her) to her rise to prominence on G4’s Attack Of The Show. Her story is hardly unique, though the story of the worst day of her life (when, during an admittedly bratty phase, she treated her grandmother poorly on the very night of her grandmother’s death) is heartbreaking and easy to empathize with.

Munn’s writing style is conversational and she repeats quite a bit of information. In Suck It, Wonder Woman!, aided by Mac Montandon, Munn writes like a high school girl talks. She writes enthusiastically, tells her stories in a rambling manner with little points and the stories are easy to read and get through. So, for example, when discussing her Playboy cover shoot, she writes “Playboy then said that if I flash the same amount of skin that Heidi had, they would pay me a certain amount – I’m not gonna reveal too much here (it’s a trend!) but suffice it to say it was a very good amount of money” (119). That type of voice with its own interjections is very common in Suck It, Wonder Woman!.

Moreover, there is an irksome trend in Suck It, Wonder Woman! where Munn oscillates between namedropping (like Evander Holyfield) and protecting the identities of those to whom she alludes (a famous movie director whose bedroom she visited, yet remains unnammed). As well, references to her show, Attack Of The Show come out of nowhere and she assumes readers are invested in the work. She spends a lot of time writing about a petition that led to her and her co-host jumping into a giant pie while wearing french maid outfits. This incident includes Munn complaining about hitting a support bar and getting hurt on it and her co-host leaping in minutes later to the same fare, leaving the reader baffled as to why she did not warn her co-host about the peril!

Suck It, Wonder Woman! has moments of entertainment value, but on the whole, the book does not stack up as a memoir, an autobiography or a book of philosophies. Instead, it is a meandering narrative that never becomes anything cohesive. Munn might have something to say, but in Suck It, Wonder Woman!, she does not land her message, nor does she stick to her personal story enough to make the reader care about the woman behind the words. In short, Suck It, Wonder Woman! is a not-unpleasant volume that undersells itself on all counts.

For other books that have memoir, philosophy or autobiographical aspects, please visit my reviews of:
The Autobiography Of Martin Luther King, Jr.
Stories I Only Tell My Friends By Rob Lowe
Keeping Faith By Jimmy Carter

3/10

For other book reviews, please check out my Book Review Index Page for an organized listing!

© 2013 W.L. Swarts. May not be reprinted without permission.
| | |

Entirely Derivative, But Exceptionally Entertaining, “Twilight” Is One Of Star Trek: Enterprise’s Best.


The Good: Good acting, Decent effects, Good (temporary) character development
The Bad: Plot is an amalgam of other episodes! The resolution is utterly unsatisfying.
The Basics: Despite having some clever twists on the story told in “Future Imperfect,” “Twilight” is little more than a rewrite of that episode for Star Trek: Enterprise!


One of the advantages of producing heavily-serialized television is that the creative team of the show can do long arcs for a character. The worst serialized television is just plot based, the best uses the continuing storyline to develop the characters and larger themes that the producers are trying to create. Unfortunately, Star Trek: Enterprise, in its serialized third season, went with the plot-based focus and “Twilight” emerges as the critical point where that becomes truly unfortunate. “Twilight” is another episode where Archer is having the crap kicked out of him in the Expanse and if Star Trek: Enterprise was a character-based show, this would be leading to a climax of the season where Captain Archer could commit an act of sacrifice to save humanity and, in the process, find relief from the ass-kicking he has been getting. So far since entering the Expanse, Archer has gotten into a number of physical altercations, was turned into an alien lifeform in “Extinction” (reviewed here!) (which, I swear, I only just now realized was a pathetic rewriting of “Identity Crisis,” reviewed here!), and in “Twilight,” he is infected with the brain worms. At some point, death has to be a relief for a character and the heroic demise of said character becomes more of a relief to the fans than watching them suffer.

But that is the premise of well-constructed serialized television. Instead, though, “Twilight” ends up as a rewrite of “Future Imperfect” (reviewed here!) and the fact that it is combined with the plot conceit of 50 First Dates (reviewed here!), does not improve the premise. It’s too bad because if “Twilight” were not a thoroughly derivative episode, it might actually be all right. “Twilight” blends “Future Imperfect” with “Resolutions” (reviewed here!) and 50 First Dates. The net result of the episode, though, for fans of the Star Trek franchise is that this is nothing new.

After having a vision where Archer, no longer the Captain of the Enterprise, bursts onto the bridge during a battle and witnesses the destruction of Earth, Archer awakens on a planet. There, T’Pol tells him that his last memories – walking down a corridor chatting with him – were twelve years old. In that memory, the Enterprise hits the usual anomalies within the Expanse and when part of the corridor collapses, T’Pol is trapped under a beam. When Archer rescues her, another anomaly hits and he is knocked unconscious. He awakens in Sickbay and is told he has brain parasites that prevent him from forming new long-term memories.

T’Pol tells Archer the story of her command of the Enterprise; from Admiral Forrest relieving Archer of duty and T’Pol taking over to a disastrous encounter with two Xindi ships to the failure of Enterprise’s mission after the Xindi wiped out all but six thousand humans. T’Pol tells Archer that they have settled on Ceti Alpha V. Phlox visits to tell Archer that he may have finally found a way to eradicate the parasites and Archer, T’Pol, and Phlox visit Enterprise to remove the parasites.

Writer Mike Sussman deserves a lot of credit, despite how he cobbled together “Twilight” from other Star Trek episodes and concepts. Sussman has a decent sense of irony; he has Archer infected with brain parasites shortly before he reveals that T’Pol and Archer have settled on Ceti Alpha V, where Khan’s people were killed off by brain worms in Star Trek II: The Wrath Of Khan (reviewed here!). Sussman has a nice sense of Star Trek history and he can write, but “Twilight” asks far too much of the viewer and sets up an obvious reversal early on.

Like “Future Imperfect,” “Twilight” plays with how the crew of the Enterprise would change over the course of twelve years. In the penultimate act, the viewer is delighted with seeing how the crew has aged and been promoted, much like seeing Ambassador Picard and the scarred Worf in “Future Imperfect.” The obvious ending to “Twilight” forces the timeline to be restored and Sussman has to do so with a temporal anomaly, which becomes obvious the moment the episode features scenes that have nothing to do with Archer in the future. Until that point in “Twilight,” the episode could be a horrible dream of Archer’s that is forcing him to see things like the destruction of Earth (if it were a dream, the destruction of Earth would not need to be undone).

Even knowing that the reversal is coming (because it has to!), the timeline of the resolution is entirely unsatisfying. Given the level of damage to the Enterprise, there should not have been enough time to resolve the episode the way it does.

What saves “Twilight” from damnation is the fact that the acting is wonderful and writer Mike Sussman and director Robert Duncan McNeill use the time to explore the characters, better than almost any other episode of Star Trek: Enterprise! T’Pol and Dr. Phlox both grow in the alternate timeline exceptionally well. T’Pol is subtly emotional and that plays well given how much she would have been “contaminated” by the constant emotionalism of Archer and her feelings of indebtedness to him.

Jolene Blalock gives one of the most subtle performances of her run on Enterprise in “Twilight.” “Twilight” gives her the chance to play emotional without breaking the character of T’Pol. Scott Bakula manages to play Archer without stiffness or a confusion that is offputting. Instead, he seems realistically shaken, but it plays to the character’s problem as opposed to being an issue of acting. Even Connor Trinneer plays Captain Tucker well enough to convince viewers that he has actually been in command for some time.

“Twilight” is a bottle episode within a heavily-serialized season and it uses some of the same conceits as the episode upon which it was based (Ambassador Soval shows up at almost the same time as Ambassador Tomalak in “Future Imperfect!”), but it is enjoyable, entertaining, and has enough (even temporary) character development to satisfy fans.

The three biggest gaffes in “Twilight:”
3. Archer and T’Pol are shot by the same weapons in the episode’s climax. Archer is able to shrug off the effects of the blast while T’Pol is either killed or stunned; this contrary to everything previously established about Vulcan and human endurance levels,
2. The Xindi are wearing uniforms clearly recycled from the Reman costumes from Star Trek: Nemesis (reviewed here!),
1. The Enterprise in Star Trek was on a five year mission exploring out beyond where anyone had ever been when it found Khan’s ship in “Space Seed” (reviewed here!). As a result, the NX-01 Enterprise should have been nowhere near Ceti Alpha V to settle there!

[Knowing that single episodes are an inefficient way to get episodes, it's worth looking into Star Trek: Enterprise - The Complete Third Season on DVD or Blu-Ray, which is also a better economical choice than buying individual episodes. Read my review of the penultimate season here!
Thanks!]

7/10

For other Star Trek episode and movie reviews, please visit my Star Trek Review Index Page!

© 2013 W.L. Swarts. May not be reprinted without permission.
| | |