Showing posts with label The Walking Dead. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Walking Dead. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 22, 2017

Finally! Hallmark Delivers An Essential The Walking Dead Ornament With Michonne!


The Good: Wonderful sculpt, Good balance, Decent coloring details.
The Bad: A little pricy, Shirt coloring.
The Basics: The 2017 Michonne The Walking Dead ornament is a wonderful genre ornament that might finally bring fans of AMC's hit show into the ornament market!


Hallmark has been picking up licenses for new genre ornaments for years, but the truth is their reach has, occasionally, exceeded their grasp. I like ambition and Hallmark certainly is ambitious with its acquisitions. But executing the new series' has not always been successful. For The Walking Dead, Hallmark has had a rocky road. With ornaments for Rick Grimes (reviewed here!) and Daryl Dixon (reviewed here!) being overproduced and underwhelming on the quality fronts, The Walking Dead has not taken off as an ornament franchise for Hallmark.

But, in 2017, Hallmark proves that the third time is a charm with the Michonne ornament from The Walking Dead!

Ever since Michonne burst into the narrative of The Walking Dead in Season Three (reviewed here!), she has been a fan favorite. Michonne arrived with her sword and two Walkers she had neutered for camouflage and captured the interest of the television show viewers and those who had read the source material and were eagerly awaiting her appearance.

It is Michonne, holding her sword in an action pose as if she has just stabbed downward or is blocking an incoming blow, that is the subject of the 2017 Michonne Hallmark ornament.

Basics

The 2017 Michonne ornament recreates Michonne, as played by Danai Gurira, with a great deal of accuracy for both the sculpt and the coloring. The ornament, released in 2017, is a wonderful recreation of the character as she appeared recently in The Walking Dead. Hallmark made the facial sculpt of the ornament is perfect; it is not simply the sword that makes the Michonne ornament appear to be the character - this ornament looks just like the character!

Measuring four and three-quarters inches tall by two inches wide by two and one and a quarter inches deep, the Michonne ornament is the only The Walking Dead ornament released by Hallmark in stores in 2017 and was released at Gold Crown Hallmark stores on Ornament Debut Weekend in October. The Michonne ornament came with an original retail price of $17.95 and, despite the quality of the ornament, that price seemed a bit steep for an ornament that did not have a sound or light function to it.

The Hallmark Michonne ornament is made of durable plastic. Michonne’s costume is simple, basically a black, sleeveless, t-shirt and leather pants, but she is accurately detailed. Michonne is holding the sword in a defensive position and Hallmark paid attention to details like the lacing on the sword's hilt.

The coloring on the Michonne ornament is pretty wonderful. Michonne's skin tones are beautifully rendered in a chocolate brown plastic and paint job that pops against the gray of her sword and the coloring of her dreads, which have realistic depth and shading to them. Michonne's pants and boots are colored to appear somewhat weathered, which makes sense given the very dirty world of The Walking Dead. In fact, the only coloring detail that is a little off is Michonne's shirt; the contrast between the shirt and skin is not significant enough to make the garment pop and that does not looks as good as it could, especially in low lighting.

Features

As a Hallmark Keepsake ornament, Michonne could have a sound chip. Given how many good lines Michonne has in The Walking Dead, it is surprising that Hallmark opted against doing a sound clip for the ornament. But, Michonne with her sword is more than enough to carry the ornament!

Balance

As with all ornaments, the intent of the Hallmark Keepsake Michonne ornament is to be hung on a Christmas Tree. For those creating the ultimate pop culture Christmas Tree, the Michonne ornament is an incredibly good addition. The ornament has a steel hook loop embedded into the top of Michonne's head and from there, the ornament hangs perfectly balanced!

Collectibility

Hallmark Keepsake began delving into the collectibles market in 1991 with Star Trek when it introduced the exceptionally limited edition U.S.S. Enterprise ornament (reviewed here!). Since then, they have made ornament replicas of almost all major franchises like DC comics, The Wizard Of Oz and Harry Potter. The Michonne ornament has not yet sold out at any Hallmark's I've found, but it is the first The Walking Dead ornament that deserves to sell out prior to the holidays! One suspects that the more fans who come across this ornament and see its quality, the faster it will sell!

Overview

Fans of Michonne, Danai Gurira, and The Walking Dead might balk at the initial release price of the 2017 Michonne ornament, but it is hard not to figure that the quality of the ornament will justify the price to most fans!

For other genre-themed character Hallmark ornaments, please check out my reviews of:
2017 Captain Jean-Luc Picard and Commander Data Star Trek: The Next Generation ornament
2017 Thor Thor: Ragnarok ornament
2017 Rey Star Wars: The Last Jedi ornament

8.5/10

For other ornament reviews, please visit my Ornament Review Index Page for an organized listing!

© 2017 W.L. Swarts. May not be reprinted without permission.
| | |

Sunday, April 2, 2017

Humans Are The Enemy Again In The Walking Dead Season 7!


The Good: Decent performances, Moments of character, Decent effects
The Bad: Entirely oppressive tone, Dull plot, Some unremarkable character moments
The Basics: In The Walking Dead Season 7, the survivalist horror once again turns to humans as the primary enemy when Negan asserts his control over the Alexandria community.


In the graphic novels of The Walking Dead, there came a point where I gave up on the franchise. That point was when the storyline shifted from the Walker threat to the massive human threat in the Story Of Survival Horror. That volume (reviewed here!) was when the books became obsessed with the Alexandria Safe Zone coming under the heel of Negan and the brutal tactics he used to keep the people there - and in other, neighboring, communities in line. I have been generally fond of the television show The Walking Dead, so I was a bit wary when the show started hinting to the presence of Negan nearby in The Walking Dead Season 6 (reviewed here!). The Walking Dead Season 7 fully reaches the point where I got tired of the books as Negan is present in full force and the sixteen-episode seventh season takes time illustrating what life under the thumb of the Saviors is like and then transitions into Rick Grimes slowly working to build a coalition against him.

Unfortunately, just like in the books, The Walking Dead Season Seven has an oppressive tone as Rick Grimes is emotionally broken by Negan and the Saviors terrorize Alexandria, Hilltop, and the new community, The Kingdom. When the episodes in the seventh season are not draining the emotional life out of the viewer with the threat of any character being summarily executed by Negan or one of his many thugs - or being tortured on-screen - the show meanders into terribly boring territory where nothing much happens. As a season, The Walking Dead Season 7 focuses almost exclusively on the human threat to Rick Grimes and his community, with minimal walker attacks. Season 7 is very much where the television incarnation of The Walking Dead commits to being a Survival Horror story, as opposed to a television show about zombies overrunning the Southeast United States.

Rick Grimes is absolutely broken the night he and others from the Alexandria Safe Zone desperately attempted to get the sick, pregnant Maggie to Hilltop. That night, Negan beat Abraham to death and when Darryl threatened Negan, he killed Glenn as well. After being tormented for a day by Negan, Rick returns to Alexandria where the Saviors take at least half of the community's possessions. Darryl is taken by the Saviors and Carol recovers from her wounds in The Kingdom, while Tara makes her way back to Alexandria - meeting a reclusive community whose male population was executed by Negan on the way.

After multiple acts of violence and oppression by the Saviors, Carl hitches a ride on a Savior vehicle and gets caught by Negan in his compound. When Negan brings Carl back to Alexandria, he kills more people and responds to Rosita taking a shot at him by threatening her life. With the body count rising and Eugene taken by the Saviors, Rick and Michonne rally to start fighting the Saviors. To that end, they reach out to Hilltop, The Kingdom, and Oceanside to create an army to fight the Saviors. But the fear of Negan has permeated the area and making new friends and getting others to step up to fight the Saviors only makes the body count rise!

The plot in the seventh season of The Walking Dead is unfortunately undermined by some key problems in the characters in the show. Chief among these issues comes near the middle of the seventh season. Early in the season, Eugene helps Rosita make a bullet, after Negan and the Saviors have taken the vast majority of the community's guns. After an aggravating moment where Olivia turns an accurate ledger of the community's firearms over to the Saviors (if they never saw the inventory, the Saviors would be unable to menace the community by looking for guns they know should be there), Rosita takes her shot at Negan with disastrous results. In that moment, the cowardly Eugene confesses to making the bullet Rosita fired and this completely undermines the intelligence and ingenuity of Eugene. As Rosita is menaced and Negan demands to know who made the bullet, Eugene has the opportunity to save himself and others by telling Negan that it was Abraham who made the bullet and that no one living in Alexandria now knows where he made the bullet or how to make them. But, instead, he (virtually) pisses his pants and confesses.

After a series of meandering episodes that belabor the oppression of the Saviors and how spread out the protagonists of The Walking Dead are following the events of the sixth season finale, the season's built-in traps are sprung as Rick and his crew begin to try to form alliances. Tara breaks her word to the women who saved her life, Maggie and Jesus begin to effectively take over Hilltop by training the people there and Morgan and Carol find themselves bringing the reluctant Kingdom to the horrible truth that Negan cannot be trusted.

As with the prior seasons, the seventh season of The Walking Dead tries to keep viewers caring about the show's primary characters. In the seventh season of The Walking Dead, the essential characters are:

Rick – Absolutely broken by Abraham and Glenn being brained before him and threatened by Negan with having to cut off Carl's arm, he returns to Alexandria utterly unwilling to fight the Saviors. After several scavenging runs intended to keep his people alive while providing material for the Saviors, his relationship with Michonne begins to suffer. When Negan visits Alexandria - to return the wayward Carl - and kills his last lingering enemy in the community, he begins to scavenge for new guns and visits other communities to try to gain new allies. He risks his life to meet with Ezekiel, of the Kingdom, and a dangerous woman whose community lives in a junkyard near the Saviors' sanctuary. As he resolves to fight, he comes alive once again,

Michonne – Upset by the first meeting with Negan, she is instantly determined to fight Negan, despite the potential consequences. She begins to explore on her own, including scouting out the Saviors' territory. She is frustrated with Rick's unwillingness to fight Negan and is excited when he finally comes around. She continues to be protective of Carl and is shocked when Rick tells her the truth about Judith,

Maggie – After Glenn is executed by Negan, she hides out at the Hilltop, with Rick telling Negan she is dead. At the Hilltop, she begins to get tired of how Gregory kowtows to the Saviors. She and Jesus begin to work together to train the Hilltop community and keep each other alive. She does not blame Darryl for getting Glenn killed and she is eager to fight the Saviors rather than live under their heel,

Darryl – Recognized by Negan as a threat, he is taken to the Saviors compound and kept imprisoned. Dwight attempts to break him, but he remains unbroken by the Saviors. When his life is menaced and an opportunity opens, he is freed by Dwight's ex-wife and he is kept hidden at the Hilltop. He learns that Carol is alive and lies to her for her own mental health. He is eager to fight the Saviors,

Carol – After fleeing because she does not want to kill for those she loves, she is mortally wounded. Rescued by Morgan and people from The Kingdom, she wakes up in Ezekiel's community. Ezekiel has an arrangement with the Saviors that his people do not know about and Carol refuses to join his community, living just outside his community. When she is visited by Darryl and The Kingdom suffers some losses, she has Morgan tell her the truth about what is going on outside her cabin and she has to make an important decision,

Carl – Shocked by how Negan killed his friends and used Rick to menace him, he becomes determined to kill Negan. Given the chance, though, he is unable to kill his new enemy and Negan begins to mess with his head. Returned to Alexandria, he is shocked to still be alive and he eagerly joins every raid that might give him a chance to get revenge,

Father Gabriel - He talks Rosita down from recklessly attacking Negan. As Alexandria starts to take the lead in creating an army, he acts as the community's ambassador to one of the new communities in the area,

Tara - Out on patrol during the carnage from Negan's introduction, she loses Heath to a Walker attack and ends up at an isolated all-female community. There, she struggles to convince the women there not to kill her and she goes free, returning to Alexandria with the secret of Oceanside and its stash of weapons. When Rick opts to fight, she makes the difficult decision to break her promise to Oceanside to get weapons to fight the community that murdered her girlfriend,

Sasha - Shaken by Abraham's murder, she moves into Hilltop with Maggie. But when Rosita wants to kill Negan, she joins her on a suicide mission to stop the despot before he can kill more of their friends,

Eugene - As Negan exerts control over Alexandria, he gets the bullet manufacturing factory running enough to make Rosita a bullet. When Negan learns of his talents, he is taken captive by Negan and he joins the Saviors to save his own life and protect himself,

Rosita - Deeply angered over Negan and Abraham getting killed before she had real resolution to her relationship with him, she becomes frustrated by Rick's capitulation. Determined to fight, she had Eugene make her a bullet and when she misses him, one of Negan's minions scars her face. She hates Negan enough to launch an attack on him in his territory rather than live under him,

Aaron - The prime scavenger for Alexandria, he and Rick find a boat with supplies in the community's first major post-Negan victory. He is beaten by Negan's people and stands up when Rick does to try to keep his loved ones safe,

Morgan - Determined to keep Carol alive, he takes her to the Kingdom, a community close to where she collapses. He begins to train some of the residents at The Kingdom in his zen ways . . . with disastrous results. When Ezekiel and his chief security advisor, Richard, differ on a course of action in dealing with the Saviors, he is put into a moral bind that tests his pacifism,

Enid - Shocked at the loss of Glenn, she follows Maggie to the Hilltop after Carl's attempts to "protect" her upset her. She takes care of Maggie through Maggie's early pregnancy,

Dwight - The Savior who Darryl met before, he returned to the Saviors when his attempt to flee failed. Horribly burned by Negan, he falls back in line with Negan to save his life and the life of his wife. Tested by Negan with the care of Darryl, he falls back in line. But when his wife is used by Negan and he is goaded by the evil leader, he starts to break. Upset by having to run down defectors, he starts to question his place in Negan's community,

and Negan - After killing two of Rick's closest allies and breaking Rick, he tries to turn Darryl. He dispenses justice in his community with brutality and a de facto caste system. When Carl visits him, he torments the boy and returns him to Rick before dispatching the last of Deanna's sons. He is harsh and somewhat unhinged, but dangerously charismatic.

On the acting front, The Walking Dead is dominated by Jeffrey Dean Morgan. Morgan plays Negan and every moment he appears on screen, he steals the show. While Andrew Lincoln plays broken Rick with unsettling accuracy, Jeffrey Dean Morgan keeps the show watchably by delivering the craziest lines with plausibility. Danai Gurira (Michonne), Sonequa Marin-Green (Sasha) and Christian Serratos (Rosita) each have moments where they step up to deliver powerful performances that make their characters vital, but unfortunately those moments are set between long stretches in the season where there are unremarkable performances or character moments.

The result is that the seventh season of The Walking Dead meanders between horrible people doing heinous things and the boredom of watching oppressed people being beaten down, which makes for an unfortunately average season of television.

For other works from the 2016 – 2017 television season, please check out my reviews of:
Thirteen Reasons Why - Season 1
Grace And Frankie - Season 3
Iron Fist - Season 1
Love - Season 2
Santa Clarita Diet - Season 1
A Series Of Unfortunate Events - Season 1
One Day At A Time - Season 1
Travelers - Season 1
"Happy Fuckin' New Year" - Sense8
The OA - Season 1
Gilmore Girls: A Year In The Life
"Invasion!" - Arrow
"The Ghost" - Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D.
"Duet" - The Flash
"The Fellowship Of The Spear" - Legends Of Tomorrow
"Star-Crossed" - Supergirl
Luke Cage - Season 1
Stranger Things - Season 1

5/10

For other television reviews, please check out my Television Review Index Page for an organized listing!

© 2017 W.L. Swarts. May not be reprinted without permission.
| | |

Sunday, October 2, 2016

Ornament Debut Weekend's Surprise Disappointment: The 2016 Rick Grimes The Walking Dead Ornament Underwhelms!


The Good: Good basic sculpt, Coloring on the pants, Affordable
The Bad: Slightly backheavy, Facial sculpt, Coloring issues, Clean coloring on clothes and arms
The Basics: With a year to get it right, it is intensely disappointing that the 2016 Rick Grimes The Walking Dead ornament gets so many details unfortunately wrong.


Last year, when Hallmark released the Daryl Dixon Hallmark ornament (reviewed here!) to kick off the The Walking Dead ornament line, the results of Hallmark's efforts were decidedly mixed. At the various huge conventions - ComicCons in San Diego and New York City - Hallmark teased much of the 2016 ornament line. So, for at least a year, fans of Hallmark ornaments knew that the 2016 Hallmark ornament from The Walking Dead would be Rick Grimes. Sadly, with the whole year to get the ornament right, the Rick Grimes ornament vastly overwhelms fans.

Hallmark based their ornament for Rick Grimes from The Walking Dead on the iconic look and feel of the character, with his pistol drawn and at his side. For those not familiar with The Walking Dead (Season One is reviewed here!), the survivors of the zombie apocalypse in Atlanta start to follow former-sheriff Rick Grimes after he meets up with them. Up until this point in both the television series and the comic book series, the common element and the character who is most-consistently focused upon is Rick Grimes. Rick has led his survivors to safety (for as long as it ever lasts) in a prison, the Greene's farm, Alexandria, and in extricating his newfound family from Terminus and cannibals who survived that bloodbath. Rick Grimes is, essentially, the protagonist of The Walking Dead.

It is Rick Grimes, holding his pistol, in his sheriff's outfit, that is the subject of the 2016 Rick Grimes Hallmark ornament.

Basics

The 2016 Rick Grimes ornament recreates Rick Grimes, as played by Andrew Lincoln, with a fair amount of fidelity to the character's frame, if not his face. The ornament, released in 2016, is poor for an ornament based upon the character as he appeared early in The Walking Dead. Hallmark made the facial sculpt of the ornament far too round for the character - Rick Grimes is much more gaunt at all parts of The Walking Dead. The facial sculpt looks far more like Joshua Jackson than Andrew Lincoln. The coloring of Rick Grimes's beard is far too dark for the character . . . at least when the ornament has him sculpted to appear to have stuble, as opposed to a full, bushy, unkempt beard like he had when his group reached Alexandria.

Measuring four and one-half inches tall by one and seven-eighths inches wide by two and one inch deep, the Rick Grimes ornament is the only The Walking Dead ornament released by Hallmark in stores in 2016 and was released at Gold Crown Hallmark stores on Ornament Debut Weekend in October. The Rick Grimes ornament came with an original retail price of $17.95 and did not sell out at any of the Hallmark shops I visited.

The Hallmark Rick Grimes ornament is made of durable plastic. Rick Grimes’s costume is simple, but fairly accurately detailed. Rick Grimes is dressed in his sheriff's outfit, with the sleeves rolled up and his holster on is belt. He has his pistol drawn and at his side, and he is in a stance like he is bracing for trouble - either with Walkers or Shane! The pistol and Rick Grimes's hands are sculpted better than the character's face.

The Rick Grimes ornament features a version of Rick Grimes who looks more like Joshua Jackson than it does Andrew Lincoln from any point in The Walking Dead. The skin tones have a almost no depth and shading compared to the actor. Similarly, the costume is clean and simplistic, despite having minor shading to it and good sculpted details. The Rick Grimes ornament is unsettling for having over-dark stubble on the face that makes it look like he has a ridiculous beard that is colored, but not sculpted on. Furthermore, for a world that is so very dark and dirty, the fact that Rick Grimes's exposed forearms are so clean and unscarred for the Rick Grimes ornament is unsettling.

Features

As a Hallmark Keepsake ornament, Rick Grimes could have a sound chip. Given how many good lines Rick Grimes has in The Walking Dead, it is surprising that Hallmark opted against doing a sound clip for the ornament.

Balance

As with all ornaments, the intent of the Hallmark Keepsake Rick Grimes ornament is to be hung on a Christmas Tree. For those creating the ultimate pop culture Christmas Tree, the Rick Grimes ornament is a theoretically essential addition, with an awkward execution. The ornament has the standard steel hook loop embedded into the top, center of the back of Rick Grimes’s head at a pretty obvious position. From there, the ornament, when affixed to a tree with a hook, is slightly back-heavy. It is not extremely unbalanced, but it is noticeably off from a stance that would make the ornament look like he was standing straight up.

Collectibility

Hallmark Keepsake began delving into the collectibles market in 1991 with Star Trek when it introduced the exceptionally limited edition U.S.S. Enterprise ornament (reviewed here!). Since then, they have made ornament replicas of almost all major franchises like DC comics, The Wizard Of Oz and Harry Potter. The Rick Grimes ornament would be a real surprise if it sold out and/or appreciated significantly, especially because fans of The Walking Dead have a lot of merchandise available focused on Rick Grimes. Because there are action figures that are at least as well-detailed in the marketplace, the Rick Grimes ornament is a tough sell to collectors.

Overview

Fans of Rick Grimes, Andrew Lincoln, and The Walking Dead are likely to be a bit disappointed by the Rick Grimes ornament. For $17.95 and with at least a year to get it right, the Rick Grimes ornament is off on enough details to make collectors a bit disappointed by it.

For other genre-themed character Hallmark ornaments, please check out my reviews of:
2016 Ollivanders Wand Shop Harry Potter ornament
2016 Alien Queen Aliens ornament
2016 U.S.S. Enterprise Star Trek 50th Anniversary ornament

4.5/10

For other ornament reviews, please visit my Ornament Review Index Page for an organized listing!

© 2016 W.L. Swarts. May not be reprinted without permission.
| | |

Saturday, August 13, 2016

The Two Worst Nights In The Life Of Rick Grimes Bookend The Walking Dead Season 6!


The Good: Good ethical dilemma, Good characters/development, Decent effects
The Bad: Some elements are troublingly predictable, Unclear threat resolution, Irksome season finale
The Basics: The Walking Dead Season 6 sees threat from crazy humans, walkers and a dangerous new community while expanding the world of the series.


Not very long ago, one of the executive producers of The Walking Dead made the bold statement that the show had no plans to bring the character of Negan into the television show. That made me happy because when Negan entered the books (that volume of the graphic novels is reviewed here!), the series became entirely unenjoyable. It also made me excited because it seemed like the show would go in its own direction. Sadly, it did not take long in the production of the sixth season for it to be revealed that Negan would be making an appearance. In some ways, that makes sense given that where the fifth season of The Walking Dead (reviewed here!) seemed to be headed. The sixth season of The Walking Dead follows up on the threads that were set in motion in the fifth season and then advances the plot to a fairly logical conclusion.

The Walking Dead Season Six does not get to the same oppressive place that the graphic novel series did, but given that the overbearing nature of the series came after Negan arrived, it made some sense that the season is not that bad. Instead, season six of The Walking Dead finds Rick Grimes and his survivors fighting against walkers, the Wolves (crazed people who intend to brutalize and kill other people), a massive herd of invading walkers and then Negan, a nearby warlord who is exerting control over communities nearby Alexandria.

The sixth season opens with flashes between the horrible night when Morgan arrived at Alexandria and a mission the residents of Alexandria are on days later. Right near the Alexandria compound is a quarry, filled with walkers. When Rick Grimes and his friends are on a dry run to figure out how they will corral the walkers out of the quarry and send the massive herd in the opposite direction of Alexandria, a truck falls into the quarry and forces the dry run to become an active attempt to save the survivor's compound. In the days after Deanna's husband was killed, Rick and Morgan take his killer's body out to dispose of it and discover the quarry. They then set up the materials - cars, wall plates, etc. - needed to lure the walkers away. Unfortunately, while most of the community's warriors are out on the mission, Alexandria is attacked by the Wolves, who begin slaughtering the residents. While most of the residents try to hide, the members of Rick's group who stayed behind slaughter the invaders.

Unfortunately, in saving Alexandria, Rick and some of the others inadvertently bring some of the herd back to just outside the wall. When the watchtower collapses and takes out a section of wall, Alexandria is overrun by walkers. On the way back to Alexandria, Abraham and his team encounter a group of people who try to take their new tanker truck for Negan. After clearing Alexandria of walkers and reinforcing the wall, Rick takes charge and begins to lead the Alexandria community. A few weeks later, Rick and Darryl discover a scavenger who leads them to a new community, Hilltop, and there they learn the threat of Negan and the Saviors.

There are a handful of episodes that diverge from the main plot in Alexandria and those episodes focus on characters who are fleshed out. Most notable of these is an episode that features Morgan exploring his emotional journey following Rick's last visit to him outside Atlanta. The episode is notable in that most of the other one-shot character episodes come up when the character is being killed. How Morgan got sane is a surprisingly engaging episode, even if it does not fit the main narrative of the sixth season.

Similarly, near the end of the season, there is an episode that focuses on Carol and Maggie, who are at the mercy of Saviors who are holding them to trade for one of their own. That episode is absolutely brutal in a way that even the episode where an entire family is slaughtered in less than thirty seconds is not. The strength of that type of narrative is that it develops the characters and does that exceptionally well.

The sixth season of The Walking Dead deepens the characters within Rick's group and introduces a few new ones. In the sixth season of The Walking Dead, the essential characters are:

Rick – After his horrible night where he was forced to kill Pete, he leads the effort to secure Alexandria. He orders Darryl, Abraham, and Sasha to keep driving the Walkers away when Alexandria is attacked. In trying to get back to Alexandria, he cuts his hand badly and has to flee there on foot. He finds himself exceptionally attracted to Jessie, but when the wall comes down, he has to prioritize saving the lives of others. When Carl is wounded by Jessie's son, he goes into a rage and begins slaughtering walkers. After a particularly irksome day, he and Michonne become more intimate. He organizes the ruthless plan to slaughter the Saviors and save Alexandria,

Michonne – Out with Rick on the corralling mission, she recognizes that Rick killing his rival after the man is bitten is a mercy kill (something Morgan does not necessarily accept). She clashes with Heath on their way back to Alexandria over Rick's order to leave behind people who cannot keep up. She comes to believe in Deanna's vision for Alexandria. When trying to lead Jessie and her family to the quarry, she saves Carl's life. She and Rick begin a romantic relationship,

Glenn – Trapped with Deanna's incompetent son on the corralling mission when it goes bad, he and Nicholas attempt to draw walkers off by burning a building to draw them out. After Nicholas has to take out a turned former friend of his, Nicholas gets twitchy and kills himself, trapping Glenn among walkers on the wrong side of the herd. After surviving under a dumpster unable to contact Alexandria, he is rescued by Enid and the two begin traveling together. They arrive home right before the watchtower falls and commit themselves to saving Maggie. He is horrified that he might have to kill when invading the Saviors' compound. He helps Heath out and tries to protect Maggie when she is captured,

Maggie – She is out preparing a garden with Deanna when Alexandria is attacked. With Carol, she kills the invading Wolves. When Michonne and Heath make it back to Alexandria, she becomes convinced Glenn is still alive and goes out with Aaron to find him, but she finds the way completely blocked by walkers. Pregnant with Glenn's child, she willingly turns back with Aaron and awaits a sign from Glenn. When walkers overrun Alexandria, she is trapped on a guard post. She acts as the key negotiator when Jesus brings her to Hilltop. She acts as lookout when Rick organizes an attack on the Saviors, getting captured in the process. When her pregnancy develops complications, the residents of Alexandria try desperately to get her to the Hilltop community to save her life,

Darryl – After disagreeing with Rick on Rick's desire not to go looking for additional people for Alexandria, he takes his newly restored motorcycle out to lure walkers away from the quarry. In attempting to get back home after the mission, he is ambushed and finds himself in a burned-out forest, at the mercy of a new enemy. His attempt to do something kind costs him his new motorcycle and his trusty crossbow. He helps save Alexandria after the wall falls. When going out on a scavenging run later on, he is attacked by the man who stole his crossbow, setting him on a path for revenge,

Carol – After maintaining her ruse of being a simple housewife without any skills, she is forced to defend Alexandria. When the Wolves attack, she disguises herself as a Wolf and starts killing them to maintain her cover. She learns Morgan has a prisoner, but gets a concussion when the wall comes down and finds herself in his care. She squares off with Morgan and has to save Denise's life, though the weight of killing people soon begins to wear upon her. When the Alexandria group learns about the Saviors, she becomes deeply uncomfortable with how many people she has killed and protective of Maggie. Disturbed by how she has had to kill to protect Alexandria, she resolves not to kill again and leave behind Rick's group,

Carl – Defending Judith during the attack on Alexandria, he horrifies his peers by killing an invading Wolf. Jessie's oldest son gets a vendetta for him, believing he stole Enid from him. While trying to leave Alexandria after the wall falls, he is shot in the face, losing an eye. He tries to protect Enid and attempts to be a part of the mission to help Maggie,

Father Gabriel - Still a pacifist, he defends Alexandria only be incapacitating invading Wolves. He keeps Judith safe when the wall comes down. When Rick goes into a rage against walkers, he finally steps up to defend Alexandria,

Tara - Having recovered from her wounds, she tries to help Denise acclimate to being Alexandria's doctor. She gets into a romantic relationship with Denise. She quickly adopts a protective attitude to the people of Alexandria, much to the ire of Rick. She tells Denise she loves her before leaving with Heath for a two-week run,

Abraham - He and Sasha stick to the corralling mission when the horn goes off and everyone else tries to flee back to Alexandria. On the way back to Alexandria, he holes up with Sasha. He begins to express affection for Sasha. He goes out on a limb to acquire a rocket propelled grenade launcher. When making contact with the Hilltop community, he gets the strength and resolve to dump Rosita and pursue Sasha,

Sasha - She becomes the voice of reason while out driving with Abraham on the corralling mission with Abraham. She comes to the aid of Alexandria in its darkest moment. She refuses to get involved with Abraham while he is still involved with Rosita,

Eugene - Still a coward, he inspires Denise not to be cowardly when she starts practicing medicine. He starts training, reluctantly, with Rosita. He manages to overcome his cowardice on the night Rick goes apeshit on the walkers within Alexandria's walls. Shortly thereafter, he develops a plan to produce bullets for Alexandria and illustrates an ability to improvise that is shockingly effective,

Rosita - After aiding in the defense of Alexandria when the Wolves attack, she remains unphased by the attack, having seen life outside the walls. She starts training the residents of Alexandria and Eugene. After Abraham leaves, she is on her own for the very first time in her life,

Deanna - After her husband and Pete's deaths, she accepts Rick's methods and his help in defending Alexandria. She leaves the defense of Alexandria up to Rick's people, remaining with her cowardly son outside the walls in hiding during the attack. In shock after the wolves attack, she creates a plan for the Alexandria community. Unfortunately, when the wall comes down, she is wounded,

Aaron - After the attack on Alexandria, he is horrified to discover that he inadvertently led the Wolves to the community. He immediately takes responsibility for his actions and he aids Maggie in leaving the compound to search for Glenn. He exhibits a lot of loyalty to Maggie from that time forward,

Denise - Pete's replacement, she is completely unskilled at actually practicing medicine. She loses her first patient after the attack on Alexandria. She is consoled by Tara. She struggles to save the life of the man Michonne and Heath rescued and is advised by Tara. Morgan brings her to care for the Wolf he captured, which puts her in mortal jeopardy. After she is rescued from the Wolf, she saves Carl's life and stitches up Darryl. She tries to get soda pop for Tara before Tara and Heath head out for a two-week run,

Morgan - Is willingly imprisoned by Rick so Rick can determine he's all right to come into the Alexandria compound. He makes it back to Alexandria first when it is attacked by the Wolves and he inadvertently helps one flee with a gun. He encounters the Wolf he previously let live and captures him, which tests his resolve to not kill anyone else. He keeps that Wolf imprisoned in a basement in Alexandria. He objects to Rick's plan to kill Negan's Saviors,

Heath - One of the Alexandria community's residents who was on a run for weeks when Rick's group arrived, he is part of Rick's mission when Alexandria is attacked. He is horrified to hear Rick tell Glenn and Michonne that not everyone will make it and thrown off when Rick scavenges from the body of a resident who is killed. He is very competent and he strives to keep people from the community alive when the corralling mission goes south. He and Glenn debate Rick's plan to kill Negan's people; he managed to not kill a living person before,

and Enid - Having survived before Alexandria on her own, she starts to bond with Carl. When the Wolves attack Alexandria, she stays with Carl. Once the fighting is over, however, she leaps the wall and flees the safety of the compound. She finds Glenn and reluctantly begins to travel with him back to Alexandria. Once back within the walls, she bonds with Maggie.

The sixth season of The Walking Dead is an effective season of growth that does not simply feel like it is a transition between getting to Alexandria and the rise of Negan. In many ways, season six of The Walking Dead feels like what the prison would have been for Rick's survivors had Andrea not ended up with the Governor. In some ways, it is even more unfortunate that the show decided to add Negan as he seems - in his very brief time in the sixth season - like a cheap retread of The Governor. Fortunately, there is so much character development and actual things that happen, that it is hard not to feel satisfied by season six.

In fact, the only real serious problem with the plotting for season six of The Walking Dead is that when the Wolves attack and Alexandria is overrun, it is not clear whether the threat from the Wolves still exists. Morgan and Carol fail to interrogate the captured Wolf to find out basic information like where they are based, how many of them there are and how many were part of the attack on Alexandria. As a result, the time lapse that occurs late in the season feels somewhat problematic in that it makes no real sense that the Wolves do not attack in that period . . . if they still exist at all.

On the acting front, The Walking Dead Season 6 hones the talents of all of the major players. Newer characters like Eugene (played by Josh McDermitt), Tara (Alanna Masterson) and Denise (Merrit Weaver) are all given substantive moments in the sixth season. Steven Yuen, Andrew Lincoln, Melissa McBride, Danai Gurira, and Lauren Cohan are all given enough to do to keep their characters interesting and push the envelope for their performances forward.

Ultimately, the sixth season of The Walking Dead holds up incredibly well, especially when binge-watched!

For other works from the 2015 – 2016 television season, please check out my reviews of:
Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt - Season 2
Legends Of Tomorrow - Season 1
Jessica Jones - Season 1
Daredevil - Season 2
House Of Cards - Season 4
Doctor Who - Season 9

7.5/10

For other television reviews, please check out my Television Review Index Page for an organized listing!

© 2016 W.L. Swarts. May not be reprinted without permission.
| | |

Saturday, October 3, 2015

HAPPY ORNAMENT RELEASE WEEKEND! An Odd Mix Of Amazing Detailing And Simplicity Mars The Daryl Dixon Ornament!


The Good: Good sculpt, Coloring on the pants, Affordable, Incredible sculpted detailing on the crossbow
The Bad: Odd foot position, Clean coloring
The Basics: The Hallmark debut of their The Walking Dead ornament line comes with Daryl Dixon, who proves too tough to render for the ornament company.


It is Hallmark Ornament Release Weekend, which means I've spent the day going hither and yon picking up Hallmark ornaments and evaluating some of the others for review. One of the ornaments I was most excited about with November Release was the Daryl Dixon ornament. It is telling of the popularity of Daryl Dixon that the first ornament Hallmark would release from their ornament line focused on The Walking Dead would be Daryl and not Rick Grimes (he'll be making his appearance next year!). From the moment Daryl Dixon was announced as a Hallmark ornament, I had a mix of excitement and wariness. As little as they want to acknowledge it, Hallmark is competing in a market where perfection in such a small scale is possible. Hallmark seldom attains perfection with its character ornaments because they are not utilizing the same technology as the companies manufacturing action figures in the 4" scale. Sadly, my feelings of trepidation won out when I finally saw the "live" version of the Daryl Dixon Hallmark ornament today.

Hallmark based their ornament for Daryl Dixon from The Walking Dead on pretty much the iconic look and feel of the character, with his crossbow. For those not familiar with The Walking Dead (Season One is reviewed here!), the survivors of the zombie apocalypse in Atlanta are initially fed by Daryl Dixon. While his brother pisses off everyone in the group, Daryl is out hunting to feed the group. Throughout the series, Daryl becomes an indispensable defender of the group, executing the will of Rick Grimes when such things are necessary.

It is Daryl Dixon, holding his crossbow, that is the subject of the 2015 Daryl Dixon Hallmark ornament.

Basics

The 2015 Daryl Dixon ornament recreates Daryl Dixon, as played by Norman Reedus, with a fair amount of fidelity. Rather amazingly, Hallmark gets the antiheroes crossbow perfectly right, while Daryl himself is executed as more of a mixed bag. The ornament, released in 2015, is fair for an ornament based upon the character as he appeared early in The Walking Dead. Measuring four and one-quarter inches tall by one and three-quarter inches wide by two and one-half inches deep, the Daryl Dixon ornament is the only The Walking Dead ornament released by Hallmark in stores in 2015 and was released at Gold Crown Hallmark stores on Ornament Release Weekend in November. The Daryl Dixon ornament came with an original retail price of $17.95 and it seems unlikely that it will sell out at that price.

The Hallmark Daryl Dixon ornament is made of durable plastic. Daryl Dixon’s costume is simple, but accurately detailed. Daryl Dixon is dressed in a simple sleeveless shirt and pants that look like leather and are filthy. He is fairly well-muscled and he is holding his crossbow in a two handed grip. Daryl Dixon stands in a weird way. Daryl Dixon's feet have him standing like he is in the process of moving or standing on unlevel ground, which is a little awkward. The crossbow is immaculately sculpted, with the string sculpted into it, making it look like it is locked and loaded with a bolt ready to shoot!

The Daryl Dixon ornament features a version of Daryl Dixon who looks more like an animated version of the character than the live-action one based on the actor from The Walking Dead. The skin tones have a almost no depth and shading compared to the actor. Similarly, the costume is clean and simplistic and it seems incongruent with the character's pants. The amazing thing about the Daryl Dixon ornament is that his pants are colored with subtle browns and blacks that make them look filthy, which is perfectly appropriate for the character. But the fletchings on his crossbow bolts are painted bright green and his skin and leather-looking shirt are cleanly colored. For a character who usually has an oily looking skin the fact that his cheeks are not even minorly dirty is problematic. Given that there is an action figure in a similar scale that has the coloring right, the Hallmark Daryl Dixon underwhelms some.

Features

As a Hallmark Keepsake ornament, Daryl Dixon could have a sound chip or light-up function. Given how many good lines Daryl Dixon has in The Walking Dead, it is surprising that Hallmark opted against doing a sound clip for the ornament.

Balance

As with all ornaments, the intent of the Hallmark Keepsake Daryl Dixon ornament is to be hung on a Christmas Tree. For those creating the ultimate pop culture Christmas Tree, the Daryl Dixon ornament is a hit or miss addition. Oddly, the ornament is well-balanced, but because of his weird foot position, it looks like he is doing some weird ho-down dance foot move. The ornament has the standard steel hook loop embedded into the top, center of the back of Daryl Dixon’s head at a pretty obvious position. From there, the ornament, when affixed to a tree with a hook, swings very easily and is well-balanced.

Collectibility

Hallmark Keepsake began delving into the collectibles market in 1991 with Star Trek when it introduced the exceptionally limited edition U.S.S. Enterprise ornament (reviewed here!). Since then, they have made ornament replicas of almost all major franchises like DC comics, The Wizard Of Oz and Harry Potter. The Daryl Dixon ornament would be a real surprise if it sold out and/or appreciated significantly, especially because fans of The Walking Dead have a lot of merchandise available focused on Daryl Dixon. In other words, fans can afford to be choosy and it is hard to believe a lot of them will choose this ornament up front.

Overview

Fans of Daryl Dixon, Norman Reedus, and The Walking Dead are likely to be somewhat underwhelmed by the Daryl Dixon ornament. It is not bad, but fans might have wanted better, especially for the initial price of $17.95.

For other genre-themed character Hallmark ornaments, please check out my reviews of:
2015 Lynda Carter As Wonder Woman ornament
2015 Star Wars Admiral Ackbar ornament
2015 Legends Of Star Trek Lieutenant Nyota Uhura ornament

5/10

For other ornament reviews, please visit my Ornament Review Index Page for an organized listing!

© 2015 W.L. Swarts. May not be reprinted without permission.
| | |

Saturday, July 4, 2015

On The Road Again, The Walking Dead Season Five Mirrors The First . . . With More Developed Characters!


The Good: Character development, Good performances
The Bad: Very light on plot developments/originality
The Basics: The Walking Dead Season 5 is a season that takes time to develop the characters viewers know . . . and makes for a season that holds up much better for binge watching than fans might expect!


Recently, I read an article that asserted that streaming television services like Netflix are ruining television. The crux of the argument was that television shows needed time and space to breathe between episodes and the relatively new trend of binge watching has destroyed that space. Some of the shows that the article cited, like works by Aaron Sorkin, do not suffer from being watched all together and many shows fare poorer when binge watched because viewers are much more easily able to catch inconstencies within the series. Bad writing is not the same as a show needing space to breathe. Interestingly, some of the most popular shows hold up better by binge watching as opposed to waiting weeks between episodes to get the next one. The Walking Dead Season Five is one such season of television.

In its fifth season, The Walking Dead actually returns more to its roots, though most fans seemed irked by the way it meandered and very little happened. Despite those complaints, the latest season of The Walking Dead has a lot in common, in terms of plot structure, with the first season of the show (reviewed here!). Like the first season, the primary characters in the fifth season find themselves fleeing a bad situation until they find a place that gives them some feeling of hope and security. Instead of working to establish the full cast, though, the fifth season of The Walking Dead fleshes out the characters who have joined the cast over the years and develops them with the changing world in which they find themselves. The fifth season of The Walking Dead picks up immediately after Season Four (reviewed here!) and it is impossible to discuss the fifth season without some spoilers on where the fourth season left the characters.

Opening in a box car at Terminus, the survivors who had been separated are (mostly) all back together and now facing a common enemy. Led by Rick, they attempt to mount a resistance against the people running Terminus. The residents of Terminus are cannibals and when Rick, Darryl, Bob and Glenn are taken to the meat processing plant, only a disruption outside the bloody plant gives them the opportunity to escape. Their escape is orchestrated by Carol, who catches up to the group with Tyreese at Terminus and liberates her friends. The group takes up refuge in a church near Terminus, where they are preyed upon by the survivors of the massacre at Terminus. The survivors split after a particularly bloody incident, with Glenn accompanying Abraham's group on a trip to Washington, D.C.

But when Abraham's group is forced to turn back and casualties within the group begin to mount, Rick's group struggles together to make it to Washington. The trip on the road is exhausting and leaves the survivors at the mercy of the elements and walkers. It also allows a scout from a nearby community to find and evaluate Rick's group. Approached by Aaron, Rick's group decides - mostly against Rick's wishes - to accompany him to the community at Alexandria. There, they try to find a new purpose and rebuild a society, but find the people who have been living there are unfortunately unprepared for all that the world has become.

The fifth season of The Walking Dead continues well the emotional journey of Rick Grimes. After struggling with himself to avoid his own darker instincts, Rick taps into them to help Carol liberate everyone from Terminus. What brilliance comes in the fifth season of The Walking Dead comes from the idea that it is impossible to utilize violence without it having a profound effect on a person. Faced with a good thing, Rick is unable to recognize it. The world might need Rick Grimes to keep some people alive, but Rick Grimes needs other people to help pull him back from "survival mode." In the fifth season, Bob, Michonne, Darryl, and Carl fill the niche vacated by Hershel, trying to remind Rick of his humanity and help him survive within a community.

The episodes in the fifth season of The Walking Dead are more cerebral, intimate and unsettling than most of the prior seasons. While the books in The Walking Dead series very quickly leapt into exploring the horrors of humans (The Governor repeatedly raped Michonne and lopped off one of Rick's hands!), it is the fifth season of The Walking Dead that most explicitly illustrates just how much humanity has degenerated. Opening with cannibals who make multiple attempts to harvest Rick and his people, the fifth season is upsetting with rapists in authority positions, cowards and the rising threat of people who openly hunt other humans.

The fifth season of The Walking Dead deepens the characters within Rick's group and introduces a few new ones. In the fifth season of The Walking Dead, the essential characters are:

Rick – Having managed to survive Terminus, he allies with Carol and together they lead the group out of danger. After encountering Father Gabriel, he and his group take up at Gabriel's church. He remains holed up at the church while Abraham leads part of the group to Washington. After they reunite following the attempt to rescue Beth, he inists on trying to get Noah home. He is wary when they are met by Aaron, but wants to keep the residents of the Alexandria settlement safe,

Michonne – Eager not to lose her humanity, she advocates taking up residence in Noah's community and then in Alexandria. She remains a formidable opponent and one of the few people that Rick actually trusts. She stands against Rick's authority when he is reluctant to join a society and start a new life there,

Glenn – Unsettled at Terminus when he is forced to kill a survivor who was harvested and is unable to accept life, he desperately wants to find a safe place for himself and Maggie. He pledges himself to Abraham when Abraham is committed to getting Eugene to Washington. When the group reaches Alexandria, he is disturbed by how the men who go out on supply runs are reckless. He finds himself at the mercy of a very human enemy,

Maggie – Relegated to a supporting role for much of the season, she is eager to find Beth. After the incident at the hospital, she is more or less lost. She is not impressed by Father Gabriel and when the group reaches Alexandria, she becomes a liaison to the local government,

Darryl – After Terminus, he and Carol are not able to resume their relationship. The rift between them gets worse after the hospital incident and he finds it impossible to assimilate after the group reaches Alexandria. He accompanies Aaron on missions to try to find more people worthy of Alexandria . . . though they discover a new threat instead,

Carol – The time on her own and with Tyreese after the fall of the prison made her into a badass and she is able to rescue her friends from Terminus. After reuniting Rick and Judith, she and Darryl go looking for Beth. She ends up wounded and at the same hospital as Beth, where she is bartered for after the tense negotiations Rick and Tyreese orchestrate. In Alexandria, she pretends to be demure and is able to recognize that one of the residents is abusing his wife and child and pushes Rick to deal with that,

Tyreese – Still unsettled by the girls Carol had to put down, he tries to keep Judith safe. His struggle to retain his humanity puts the rest of the group in danger after the fall of Terminus. When trying to rescue Beth, he advocates for a more peaceful solution than Rick's use of force. In trying to get Noah home, he finds himself put in a surprisingly dangerous situation,

Carl – He shows up. In Alexandria, he makes a friend again,

Beth - Following her separation from Darryl in the prior season, she awakens at a hospital. There, she struggles to survive rapist guards and a situation where humans are kept under a dangerous authority. Her attempt to leave allows Noah to escape and when Carol arrives, she has the chance to save them both,

Father Gabriel -A priest that Rick's people rescue after Terminus, he is a coward who puts everyone at risk. He is terrified by the brutality he witnesses among Rick and his people when Rick works to defend them from the cannibals and Walkers. In Alexandria, he betrays Rick's people,

Noah - A young man stuck in the hospital Beth ends up at, he has a family and community he desperately wants to return to. After the negotiations for Beth and Carol go sideways, he helps lead the group to his community. After that, he is eager to join the Alexandria community where he wants to learn new skills to be useful in the new society there,

Tara -The former aid of the Governor after Woodbury, she continues to search for redemption. She becomes Eugene's only real friend after his deception is revealed,

Abraham - The militaristic survivor continues to be obsessed with getting Eugene to Washington, with Rosita. When Eugene confesses to him, he wigs out and nearly beats Eugene to death. In Alexandria, he steps up as a leader of the construction crew and usurps the locals who are fearful and incompetent,

Sasha - Tyreese's sister, she becomes obsessed with killing walkers and keeping people safe after Bob's death,

and Eugene - A geek who insists he has the answer to the infection that has decimated the world, he uses Abraham to try to get the group to Washington. When Abraham's group faces an impossible herd of walkers they must get through, he confesses that he lied, which almost gets him killed. In Alexandria, his technical knowledge becomes useful to the people there.

The fifth season of The Walking Dead is slow and cerebral, but punctuated by intense scenes of blood and brutality. After a truly nauseating opening that is some of the most graphic throat-slitting and eviscerations the series has yet seen, the episodes become more tense without much in the way of real grossness. Following the struggle at the church, there is a long period before graphic gore returns to the screen. The season has a body count comparable with the first season, though because of the season's obsession with fleshing out the characters, viewers are likely to get hit pretty hard by the main-cast deaths in this season.

On the acting front, the fifth season of The Walking Dead is pretty much flawless. All the performers know their characters and they hit their marks, easily creating the horrific world following the zombie apocalypse. The new and guest stars gel well with the established cast and the season holds together remarkably well, despite very little actually happening.

Ultimately, the fifth season of The Walking Dead is a rare season of television that holds up better on multiple viewings and when watched all together fleshes out the characters much better than it initially seems. This is a season that puts the essential characters in a setting where the series could conceivably end and does it well-enough that viewers actually care about them. Instead of trying to top the plot tension of the prior season's finale, The Walking Dead evolves to a place where the viewers care enough about the survivors to want to see them rest, succeed, and build something truly safe and enduring.

For other works from the 2014 – 2015 television season, please check out my reviews of:
Orange Is The New Black - Season 3
Sense8 - Season 1
Grace And Frankie - Season 1
Agent Carter - Season 1
Daredevil - Season 1
The Newsroom - Season 3
House Of Cards - Season 3
Doctor Who - Season 8
True Blood - Season 7
”Shadows” - Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D.
”City Of Heroes” - The Flash

6.5/10

For other movie reviews, please check out my Film Review Index Page for an organized listing!

© 2015 W.L. Swarts. May not be reprinted without permission.
| | |

Tuesday, February 17, 2015

Essentially The End: The Walking Dead Book Ten Escalates The Negan Threat!


The Good: None, really.
The Bad: Poor artwork, Oppressive mood, No real character development
The Basics: The Walking Dead - Book Ten finds Rick Grimes and his survivors menaced by Negan and his people.


Arguably, the benefit of reading the books in The Walking Dead is that the general direction of the television show The Walking Dead becomes known. As the graphic novel series progresses, it serves as a decent guide for measuring how worthwhile it will be to stick with the television series. Should the television series ever get to the point of The Walking Dead - Book Ten, I’m out. Given that the antagonist for this arc has just been introduced in the fifth season of The Walking Dead, I already have an exit strategy for watching the television show.

The reason for my plan to abandon the television series as it develops the conflict between Rick Grimes’s survivors and Negan is that the tone in the books has become so far beyond oppressive that there is no joy in reading it. No longer anything close to the story of surviving the zombie apocalypse, by the point of The Walking Dead - Book Ten, the villains are all human and the sense of oppression is so overwhelming that there is nothing enjoyable about suffering through reading it.

Menaced by Negan, who has made Rick’s settlement a fiefdom, Rick and his people live in constant fear that Negan and his people will subjugate them with more than just the threat of violence. Tired of having to continue to give Negan the lionshare of their supplies, Rick’s people are pushed to the breaking point. When Negan and his people come through to get their supplies, Rick has to keep his people from attacking Negan. The tensions boil over and Negan is about to kill some of Rick’s people again when Carl shoots Negan’s beloved weapon and decides he is done being a “nice guy.”

Eugene manages to manufacture more ammunition and, so bolstered, Rick leads an attack on Negan’s sanctuary. While Negan refuses to surrender, Rick’s people use the walkers and elements within Negan’s camp to assert pressure upon the local despot. But the plan does not go entirely according to Rick’s designs and he and his people find themselves risking their lives in ways they never had before.

There is nothing enjoyable about The Walking Dead - Book Ten and Negan is hardly a worthwhile villain; he’s just a bully who threatens everyone around him. Given the way he brained Glenn, the people around Alexandria and Hilltop live with reasonable fear. It’s an oppressive situation and in The Walking Dead - Book Ten Rick’s survivors are not surviving, they are being beaten down.

The artwork in The Walking Dead - Book Ten is entirely mediocre. As with many other volumes, there are several characters who look like one another and the sense of action and movement is not well-presented.

On the character front, The Walking Dead - Book Ten is where Rick has, largely, lost his own moral compass. So long ago, The Governor used Walkers as a way to menace his enemies and in The Walking Dead - Book Ten, Rick uses essentially the same tactic. Carl is threatened by Negan and he threatens Negan, which makes it hard to even consider him a child anymore.

The result is a book that makes The Walking Dead unbearable to read.
For other The Walking Dead books, check out my reviews of:
Days Gone Bye
Book One
Book Two
Book Three
Book Four
Book Five
Fear The Hunters
Life Among Them
Book Seven
Book Eight
Book Nine

0/10

For other graphic novel reviews, please check out my Graphic Novel Review Index Page for an organized listing!

© 2015 W.L. Swarts. May not be reprinted without permission.
| | |

Friday, January 30, 2015

This Is Where They Lost Me: The Walking Dead – Book Nine!


The Good: The plot progresses
The Bad: Mediocre artwork, Entirely oppressive mood, Unlikable new characters
The Basics: The Walking Dead - Book Nine marks the arrival of Negan . . . and the point where the series becomes unbearable to read.


While I was on vacation in September of last year, my wife and I visited the Mall Of America (reviewed here!). At one point, while she was shopping at stores I had no interest in, I decided to go and get some reading done at the Barnes & Noble there. I was pretty psyched at the time because there was a copy of The Walking Dead – Book Nine there (which was not available to me locally). So, while my wife shopped, I read and, alas, it quickly turned into the low point of my vacation for me.

The Walking Dead – Book Nine was unenjoyable to read because it is the point where everything in the series has built up to a point where there is such an oppressive tone that there is no joy in the experience. As horrible as what Rick and Michonne suffered at the hands of The Governor, there was at least the hope that they might overcome and thwart the leader of Woodbury. That part of The Walking Dead has a decent catharsis and it came fast-enough to make for an enjoyable, if gruesome, read. With the introduction of Negan in The Walking Dead – Book Nine, the series begins a downward spiral into misery. In fact, it becomes so unpleasant to read The Walking Dead – Book Nine that I had to pick up the subsequent volumes and skim through key plot points for one important reason: I had to know if continuing to invest in the series was going to be worth it. At the last point I skimmed to, the plotline involving Negan finally came to an end and its resolution was fairly unsatisfying. Still, I went back to finish The Walking Dead – Book Nine and it’s hard for me to imagine wanting to return to the world of The Walking Dead afterward.

On the way back to the Alexandria community from Hilltop, Rick Grimes and his party encounter a motorcycle gang. The motorcyclists are working for Negan and they demand a tribute for Negan. Michonne and Andrea kill three of the four people working for Negan. Rick sends the last one back to Negan to tell Negan to leave Hilltop alone. While Abraham and Eugene are out scavenging for ammunition, Abraham is killed and Eugene is captured. Brought to the gates of Alexandria by Dwight, Eugene is threatened, but manages to break free and give Rick’s survivors the chance to turn the tables on Negan’s people.

When Rick refuses to take things lying down, he and a small team prepare to leave for Hilltop (including Glenn and Maggie, who is now pregnant, who want to relocate to the safer location). On the road, though, they meet Negan, who menaces the group and then beats in the head of one of Rick’s closest friends with his barbed wire-covered baseball bat, which he has named Lucille. Forcing Rick into a position of fealty to him, Negan begins his oppressive reign over Alexandria. Visiting Rick’s town, Negan and his people take what they want and when Carl sneaks back with him, Carl sees just what Negan has built.

On the character front, The Walking Dead – Book Nine sees a progression of the relationship between Rick Grimes and Andrea. The change in their relationship status seems largely to provide a weird pair of mirror scenes in the book. When Carl walks in on Andrea and Rick after they have had sex, Rick avoids having “the talk” with Carl. This conversation is mirrored by a creepy “show and tell” wherein Negan gives Carl a tour of his brothel and admits that the end of the world has been better for his sex life than the world was before. The difference between the determined Rick and the sadistic Negan is played out throughout The Walking Dead – Book Nine and the genuine affection Rick has for Andrea is a foil for Negan’s careless collecting of women.

The Walking Dead – Book Nine has big, significant deaths and the siege mentality that results and the psychological torment of Carl by Negan makes for an utterly unpleasant book. There is no joy in seeing how Rick Grimes and his people survive at this point; instead, they are at a point of prolonged suffering and the sense that they will be miserable for a long time is more than just a mood in The Walking Dead – Book Nine. Rick, Maggie, Carl, and the others readers have invested their time and affection in will be suffering for books to come and given how harsh Book Nine is, it is impossible to recommend, much less recommending continuing with the series.

For other The Walking Dead books, check out my reviews of:
Days Gone Bye
Book One
Book Two
Book Three
Book Four
Book Five
Fear The Hunters
Life Among Them
Book Seven
Book Eight

2/10

For other graphic novel reviews, please check out my Graphic Novel Review Index Page for an organized listing!

© 2014 W.L. Swarts. May not be reprinted without permission.
| | |